MBIII and two first round picks for McFadden?

[dargarin]

Let's look at the facts that prove trading Barber for McFadden is definitely the wrong move. Barber has proven himself great in the NFL. He's about three TIMES better then the leagues average runner. He has 4.5 average yards in his NFL career. McFadden.. It's a gamble. So lets look at college averages. Barber has EXACTLY the same average as McFadden! They both have 5.8 average yards in their college careers! So why would you trade a player that is EQUALLY good and two first round picks that we NEED for our secondary for someone not tested in the pro's? You wouldn't.

[Jin Rummy]

There's only one thing I REALLY can't stand about this forum... Every individual topic has 50 dedicated threads. You couldn't post your thoughts in one of the other 47 McFadden draft rumor threads?

[es22]

no way you give up 2 1st round picks and MBIII, although I might consider Barber and a first.

[Rack Bauer]

There's only one thing I REALLY can't stand about this forum... Every individual topic has 50 dedicated threads. You couldn't post your thoughts in one of the other 47 McFadden draft rumor threads?

:hammer:

[big dog cowboy]

no way you give up 2 1st round picks and MBIII, although I might consider Barber and a first.
:bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

[Rack Bauer]

:bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

I might consider Barber and a first too... if we got back a 2nd, 3rd this year and a 2nd, 3rd next year.

[theogt]

Beyond stupid.

[justbob]

yep --my new way of thinking based on warped thinking from this board and the media --most people live and think 3 foot over the edge of common sense

[TwentyOne]

Let's look at the facts that prove trading Barber for McFadden is definitely the wrong move. Barber has proven himself great in the NFL. He's about three TIMES better then the leagues average runner. He has 4.5 average yards in his NFL career. McFadden.. It's a gamble. So lets look at college averages. Barber has EXACTLY the same average as McFadden! They both have 5.8 average yards in their college careers! So why would you trade a player that is EQUALLY good and two first round picks that we NEED for our secondary for someone not tested in the pro's? You wouldn't.

Maybe i missed something but i read about MB and 1 first round pick and maybe a third. Where did you get that info about 2 firsts from ?

Anyways....

Trading Barber for McFadden to me makes no sense at all. Way to much value to give up. trading MB and a first for Miami's first and trading down again for ... say 2 firsts, to me makes much more sense. we would have 3 first round picks: WR,CB and Felix Jones. I could live with that.

[OldButDeadly]

There's only one thing I REALLY can't stand about this forum... Every individual topic has 50 dedicated threads. You couldn't post your thoughts in one of the other 47 McFadden draft rumor threads?

The answer to that is.....is that his thoughts get buried on page 100 and does not get any interaction. The one thing about this site that I cannot stand is that if you are not an elite-ist poster you don't get responded to.

That is why I read mostly. Good is the info at Cowboyszone. For over 5 years been here I have.

Kev

As a matter of fact...this post will probably be ignored....LOL

[Muhast]

dont you think the 400 threads about this already were enough?

why must people post the same things over and over

this is getting to the "roy williams sucks" point

[Sarge]

:bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

Let me join you in your misery..................:bang2:

[CrazyCowboy]

I can see it both ways........my heart says do it but my brain says to pass.

[Hostile]

There's only one thing I REALLY can't stand about this forum... Every individual topic has 50 dedicated threads. You couldn't post your thoughts in one of the other 47 McFadden draft rumor threads?I expect a thread per day until the Draft comes and this deal never happens. Then 2 or 3 a week saying how we should have made that treade.

[CATCH17]

This started Saturday and its only Wednesday! :bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

[Yeagermeister]

:bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

Let me join you in your misery..................:bang2:

make that 3

:bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

[justbob]

I expect a thread per day until the Draft comes and this deal never happens. Then 2 or 3 a week saying how we should have made that treade.

For at least the next 4 years:D

[Hostile]

For at least the next 4 years:DMan, I didn't even see that kick coming. Nice aim. I'm going to go throw up now.

[ABQCOWBOY]

Man, I didn't even see that kick coming. Nice aim. I'm going to go throw up now.


Get some grass. Put your hands over your head.

All things from my past that I've heard when facing the upchuke gods.

:D

[justbob]

Man, I didn't even see that kick coming. Nice aim. I'm going to go throw up now.

Better to face the pain and reality now --then to think it will just suddenly
end ---now that you are feeling better --do you think we should have
drafted Merriman instead of Ware :laugh2:

[REDVOLUTION]

I expect a thread per day until the Draft comes and this deal never happens. Then 2 or 3 a week saying how we should have made that treade.



Never let anyone outside of the family know what you are thinking.... NOW they will post multiple threads per day.

Jerry concerns me. I think he makes this team and gives more than he should.

Barber=proven
Draft picks= unproven

I dont like it.

[Hostile]

Better to face the pain and reality now --then to think it will just suddenly
end ---now that you are feeling better --do you think we should have
drafted Merriman instead of Ware :laugh2:

Comments from 3 foot over the edge of Common sense --Got to figure out how to add that to my sigI better get a bucket of dirt up here. They can throw it over my body or I can rub some dirt on it.

[OldButDeadly]

The answer to that is.....is that his thoughts get buried on page 100 and does not get any interaction. The one thing about this site that I cannot stand is that if you are not an elite-ist poster you don't get responded to.

That is why I read mostly. Good is the info at Cowboyszone. For over 5 years been here I have.

Kev

As a matter of fact...this post will probably be ignored....LOL

Man am I good.....I may just go into business as a psychic.

[Hostile]

Man am I good.....I may just go into business as a psychic.LOL

It hardly took an advanced degree in behavioral science OBD.

Nice job nonetheless.

[REDVOLUTION]

The answer to that is.....is that his thoughts get buried on page 100 and does not get any interaction. The one thing about this site that I cannot stand is that if you are not an elite-ist poster you don't get responded to.



You make a good point.

But when you have everyday regular that constantly reload the page it gets annoying to them. I believe this stunts the growth of the forum.

If a poster posts every few days and misses something then he gets blasted for it when he starts a thread that has been started already whether it was yesterday or a few days before.

BUT... in alot of cases it is done to annoy.

Forums need a better setup or some sort of categorization.

[1fisher]

There's only one thing I REALLY can't stand about this forum... Every individual topic has 50 dedicated threads. You couldn't post your thoughts in one of the other 47 McFadden draft rumor threads?


You have the freedom to NOT open any thread. Plus, its the offseason. Get used to it!

:laugh2: :laugh2:

[rangers71]

If you don't want to read the thread don't read it. By all means don't post in it.

[CNY Cowboy]

Hey!!!!!!!!!!!!! Did you guys hear that The Boys are thinking of trading MBIII plus draft choices , for The running back from Ark.????



























just thought i'd ask.:grin:

[1fisher]

Hey!!!!!!!!!!!!! Did you guys hear that The Boys are thinking of trading MBIII plus draft choices , for The running back from Ark.????



























just thought i'd ask.:grin:

You should have started a dang thread about it!!!!:bang2:

:laugh2:

[dogberry]

Is there someone not on the current Cowboys' roster that would have been worth two first round draft choices? Brady, P. Manning, Strahan, Moss..?

Is there anyone in this draft who might push us over the top (not over the edge)?

Sedric Ellis, Chris Long, or one of the cornerbacks?

[ctrous25]

I can see it both ways........my heart says do it but my brain says to pass.

Both my heart and brain say NO!! But I will say this, it gives us cowboy fans something to debate about for 3 months:laugh2:

[Rowdy]

Good is the info at Cowboyszone. For over 5 years been here I have.

Yoda? Is that you?

[GimmeTheBall!]

Only if Jerra goes crazy on draft day.

[Tom [Giants fan]]

It would make me very happy if the Cowboys made this move.

[burmafrd]

I am thinking we need a McFadden Zone just like we had a TO Zone for a while.

[Yakuza Rich]

Let's look at the facts that prove trading Barber for McFadden is definitely the wrong move. Barber has proven himself great in the NFL. He's about three TIMES better then the leagues average runner. He has 4.5 average yards in his NFL career. McFadden.. It's a gamble. So lets look at college averages. Barber has EXACTLY the same average as McFadden! They both have 5.8 average yards in their college careers! So why would you trade a player that is EQUALLY good and two first round picks that we NEED for our secondary for someone not tested in the pro's? You wouldn't.

I wouldn't get too worked up on it. According to the media, Jerry Jones has an undesirable mancrush for former Arkansas players.

How many Arkansas players has Jones drafted?

Zero.

The last 3 Arkansas players Dallas has signed was Clint Stoerner (a guy who came in to be a #3 QB), Jermaine Brooks (an undrafted free agent that couldn't get off the practice squad), and Ken Hamlin (a good safety that filled a major need, that we signed to a 1 year deal).






YAKUZA

[REDVOLUTION]

;1933561']It would make me very happy if the Cowboys made this move.


It would make me very happy if the Giants and Plaxico eat it big time on Sunday.....

Just saying.....

[OldButDeadly]

Yoda? Is that you?

Well...maybe there is hope....someone DID read the thread and even read INTO it....

:laugh2:

Kev

[Taz]

Hey!!!!!!!!!!!!! Did you guys hear that The Boys are thinking of trading MBIII plus draft choices , for The running back from Ark.????


This might be the FIRST TIME IN HISTORY that a college has traded with a NFL team.. i wodner if they would take roy?
;)

[Nors]

No, No, No,
Lets not go there

[CowboyJeff]

I say McFadden and two 1st rounders for MB3 !!!

[CowboyJeff]

Yoda? Is that you?

Judge him by his size, do you?