Chad Johnson or Santonio Holmes

[DFWJC]

I know Chad was rated much higher (and is a great talent) before all of the baggage, but now it seems pretty even. I liike Holmes' potential and am worried about Chad's shoulder...so I'm leaning towards Holmes.

Who would you take?

[DaBoys4Life]

Chad. I had the chance to take Holmes in my fantasy league but I let him buy a couple of times. I think a #1 is almost always better than a #2.

[DFWJC]

Chad. I had the chance to take Holmes in my fantasy league but I let him buy a couple of times. I think a #1 is almost always better than a #2.

I guess the question is this: with Chad playing with a torn labrum in his shoulder all year, can he possibly make it through the season or if he does, play at a very high level (like a #1)?

[Doomsday]

Santonio, I have him ranked as the number 14 WR. Johnson isnt going to play the whole season on that shoulder. I dont think Chad is worth the risk it is rough replacing one of your top 4 players.

Holmes is number 1 in Pittsburgh anymore and you could argue that Housh is number one in Cincy.