Warner or Brees?

[WoodysGirl]

Brees is playing the Green Bay

Warner is playing the Giants

[Heisenberg]

That's a tough one. Both have pretty good pass defenses. I'd probably go Brees. I just see Warner getting knocked around pretty good against that Giants defense.

[DaBoys4Life]

Warner.

[ajk23az]

That's a tough one. Both have pretty good pass defenses. I'd probably go Brees. I just see Warner getting knocked around pretty good against that Giants defense.

Same here, the Giants will be getting to Warner all game long imo. Causing him to throw some picks.

Brees is on pace to break the NFL Record for passing, how can you sit him! (I got him too :D, Rivers is my other Qb.)

[DaBoys4Life]

Same here, the Giants will be getting to Warner all game long imo. Causing him to throw some picks.

Brees is on pace to break the NFL Record for passing, how can you sit him! (I got him too :D, Rivers is my other Qb.)

I disagree.

[ajk23az]

I disagree.

Great argument!

Dude I live in Tempe, AZ. I see EVERY Cardinals game, my most hated team besides the NFCE Rivals. The Giants have extremely smart linebackers, they arent going to allow all of those quick slants that they used non stop vs. the Seahawks and practically every other team.

The 2 TOUGH pass defenses they have played against they've lost to. the Redskins, and the Panthers.

If you don't think the Giants pass defense is good, look again. They are only giving up 174 yards a game through the air second to the all mighty steelers. Warner is going to have it tough.

The next 2 games for the Cardinals are huge, if they lose both, they will be pretenders. The ONLY decent team they beat is us, and that was without, Newman, Kosier & Felix for part of the game.

Warner is having a great year, but he is doing it to nobody teams. Romo would be throwing for 350 yards and 3 TDs a game too if we played the 49ers, Seahawks and Rams 2 times a year.

[Achozen]

Hey, I have them both on my team too and was gonna post a thread about who to start...

I'm starting Warner, btw.

[WoodysGirl]

Hey, I have them both on my team too and was gonna post a thread about who to start...

I'm starting Warner, btw.
Brees has been my default starter all year, but Warner has been putting up ridiculous numbers.

Brees, OTOH, has turned in some questionable games the last couple weeks.

[DaBoys4Life]

Great argument!

Dude I live in Tempe, AZ. I see EVERY Cardinals game, my most hated team besides the NFCE Rivals. The Giants have extremely smart linebackers, they arent going to allow all of those quick slants that they used non stop vs. the Seahawks and practically every other team.

The 2 TOUGH pass defenses they have played against they've lost to. the Redskins, and the Panthers.

If you don't think the Giants pass defense is good, look again. They are only giving up 174 yards a game through the air second to the all mighty steelers. Warner is going to have it tough.

The next 2 games for the Cardinals are huge, if they lose both, they will be pretenders. The ONLY decent team they beat is us, and that was without, Newman, Kosier & Felix for part of the game.

Warner is having a great year, but he is doing it to nobody teams. Romo would be throwing for 350 yards and 3 TDs a game too if we played the 49ers, Seahawks and Rams 2 times a year.

I live in NJ i see all Giants games. They are will get picked apart by the Cardinals. We will just see though. Fitz and Boldin will be to much for them in the end. Watch.......I think Green Bays defense will force more turnovers than NY defense.

[Sarge]

Put me down for Brees.

[ajk23az]

I live in NJ i see all Giants games. They are will get picked apart by the Cardinals. We will just see though. Fitz and Boldin will be to much for them in the end. Watch.......I think Green Bays defense will force more turnovers than NY defense.

Your thinking is here ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------->Reality is here

[DaBoys4Life]

Your thinking is here ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------->Reality is here



:rolleyes:

[WoodysGirl]

I'm going with Warner today. *crossing fingers*

[DaBoys4Life]

I'm going with Warner today. *crossing fingers*

you made the right choice.

[WoodysGirl]

you made the right choice.
I don't think I could've gone wrong with Brees either. Just switching it up cuz I don't think the Gints can cover both Boldin and Fitz.

[DaBoys4Life]

I don't think I could've gone wrong with Brees either. Just switching it up cuz I don't think the Gints can cover both Boldin and Fitz.

we'll see you could go wrong depends one could not put up more than 15 and the one of the bench could put up 40+

Good luck....I hope Warner has a huge day = win for the Cards = boys1 more step closer to winning the division.

[ajk23az]

we'll see you could go wrong depends one could not put up more than 15 and the one of the bench could put up 40+

Good luck....I hope Warner has a huge day = win for the Cards = boys1 more step closer to winning the division.

Decent day for Warner only plus is his 350 yards, the fumble and int pretty much negates his ONE td pass.

Now onto Brees tomorrow night..

[DaBoys4Life]

Decent day for Warner only plus is his 350 yards, the fumble and int pretty much negates his ONE td pass.

Now onto Brees tomorrow night..

yea he put up 30 points in my league. Normally they throw the ball instead of running it in down at the goal line.

[masomenos]

yea he put up 30 points in my league. Normally they throw the ball instead of running it in down at the goal line.

He put up 19 points in my league. Did you end up losing because of T.O.s domination?

[DaBoys4Life]

He put up 19 points in my league. Did you end up losing because of T.O.s domination?

Surprisingly I was able to make a come back. I think what hurt here was Mcgahee not giving her any points. Reggie Wayne taking a day off also helped.

[masomenos]

Surprisingly I was able to make a come back. I think what hurt here was Mcgahee not giving her any points. Reggie Wayne taking a day off also helped.

Oh nice! What's your record and rank in your league this year?

[DaBoys4Life]

Oh nice! What's your record and rank in your league this year?

after that win i'm 10-2. First place in my league. How are you doing in your league ?

[masomenos]

after that win i'm 10-2. First place in my league. How are you doing in your league ?

10-2?! Nice!

After this week I'll be 8-4 and tied for first with one other guy. Well, 8-4 assuming that Drew Brees, Donald Driver and Ryan Grant don't combine for 80+ points on Monday night. Who's on your roster?

[DaBoys4Life]

10-2?! Nice!

After this week I'll be 8-4 and tied for first with one other guy. Well, 8-4 assuming that Drew Brees, Donald Driver and Ryan Grant don't combine for 80+ points on Monday night. Who's on your roster?


Peyton Manning
Trent Edwards
Brian Wesbtrook
D'angelo Williams
Steve Slaton
Correl Bulkhater
Brandom Marshall
Greg Jennings
Andre Johnson
Desean Jackson
Antonio Gates
Anthony Fasano
Demarcus Ware
Paul Polussny
D'Qwell Jackson
Aaron Kapman
Green Bay D/st
Titans D/ST
Jason Elam

Bold are the people I started this week. I benched Westbrook because he wasn't practicing and he was going up against the Ravens. Normally it's Westbrook and Williams. what about yours?

[masomenos]

Peyton Manning
Trent Edwards
Brian Wesbtrook
D'angelo Williams
Steve Slaton
Correl Bulkhater
Brandom Marshall
Greg Jennings
Andre Johnson
Desean Jackson
Antonio Gates
Anthony Fasano
Demarcus Ware
Paul Polussny
D'Qwell Jackson
Aaron Kapman
Green Bay D/st
Titans D/ST
Jason Elam

Bold are the people I started this week. I benched Westbrook because he wasn't practicing and he was going up against the Ravens. Normally it's Westbrook and Williams.

Oh a defensive player league, cool! I've never been in one of those but I always thought it would be fun. I have Gates, Slaton and Marshall on my team too. I was actually able to pick Slaton up in FA, I dropped Maurice Morris to get him lol. I have Romo as my QB and 3 of my losses came when he was hurt. One of the losses was a tie but our league uses bench points as the tie breaker and I lost by 1. Grr.

[masomenos]

Oh and my full roster is

Tony Romo
Brady Quinn (who will be dropped this week)

Joseph Addai
Michael Turner
Steve Slaton
Warrick Dunn
Cedric Benson

Roddy White
Brandon Marshall
Kevin Curtis
Roy Williams
Rashied Davis (who I picked up and got a couple of goof weeks out of)
Mark Bradley (who I just picked up and who is doing surprisingly well)

Antonio Gates

Buccaneers D/ST

Matt Bryant

[DaBoys4Life]

Oh a defensive player league, cool! I've never been in one of those but I always thought it would be fun. I have Gates, Slaton and Marshall on my team too. I was actually able to pick Slaton up in FA, I dropped Maurice Morris to get him lol. I have Romo as my QB and 3 of my losses came when he was hurt. One of the losses was a tie but our league uses bench points as the tie breaker and I lost by 1. Grr.

ouch. Yeah it's pretty cool. I get to cheat the system a little bit since Dware is listed as a DE/LB so i put him at DE and have 3 LB in my line up instead of a DE and 2 LB'rs. ;) I drafted Slaton just because of how much hype he was getting when we played the Texans and they said he would be the featured back. Losing by one point sucks....I thinking about benching Marshall he hasn't be doing much of anything lately.

[masomenos]

Well, for my league is a points per catch league and Marshall always gets a lot of looks so I'll be keeping him in my lineup. He's had the dropsies as of late though, I'm not sure what it is. Still, he's only had 2 games that weren't double digit point games in my league though and he's still a top 10 points WR.

[DaBoys4Life]

Well, for my league is a points per catch league and Marshall always gets a lot of looks so I'll be keeping him in my lineup. He's had the dropsies as of late though, I'm not sure what it is. Still, he's only had 2 games that weren't double digit point games in my league though and he's still a top 10 points WR.

I think I'm just being greedy I want Marshall to give me the production he did in his first game this season every week....:D

[masomenos]

I think I'm just being greedy I want Marshall to give me the production he did in his first game this season every week....:D

Oh I know! It was a 41 point game for Marshall in my league, lol. I picked Marshall up in the 7th round so he's been a HUGE value pick for me.

[DaBoys4Life]

Oh I know! It was a 41 point game for Marshall in my league, lol. I picked Marshall up in the 7th round so he's been a HUGE value pick for me.

Yeah I think i picked him up around the same time. People in my league didn't want him because of the suspension. What a steal!!!!!

[ajk23az]

yea he put up 30 points in my league. Normally they throw the ball instead of running it in down at the goal line.

:rolleyes: What are the settings in your league? My GOD!?

He would have gotten 16 in my league.

[DaBoys4Life]

:rolleyes: What are the settings in your league? My GOD!?

He would have gotten 16 in my league.

TD Pass 6
Every 20 passing yards 1
Every 5 pass completions 1
300-399 yard passing game 3
400+ yard passing game 4
2pt Passing Conversion 2
Interceptions Thrown-2

for some reason the settings didn't deduct points for fumbles from anyone didn't catch that till late in the season.

[DaBoys4Life]

WG how many points da Warner score you?

[WoodysGirl]

WG how many points da Warner score you?
Warner got me 16 pts, so he was OK. I'll be tracking Brees tonight to see if I made the right decision.

I had a pretty good day overall in that league.

Moss went off - 30pts
Turner went off - 35pt
Kevin Walter did well - 15pts

[DaBoys4Life]

Warner got me 16 pts, so he was OK. I'll be tracking Brees tonight to see if I made the right decision.

I had a pretty good day overall in that league.

Moss went off - 30pts
Turner went off - 35pt
Kevin Walter did well - 15pts

wow...Your scoring is really different than mine.

[WoodysGirl]

wow...Your scoring is really different than mine.
FoxSports league... scoring is very TD-slanted. and you only get 1 pt every 25 yds. He was also penalized for fumbling.

[big dog cowboy]

Speaking of FoxSports league, anyone not in a league with them should keep it that way. It is by far the worst around.

[BraveHeartFan]

My league that I'm in does it like this...

1pt for every 20 yards passing
1pt for every 10 yards rushing
6pts for every TD

We don't deduct for INT's and fumbles but you also don't get extra points for monster games like 300-400+ yard performances.

[DaBoys4Life]

FoxSports league... scoring is very TD-slanted. and you only get 1 pt every 25 yds. He was also penalized for fumbling.

Yeah that was something that the League Manager didn't catch onto until like week 7....really lame IMO.

My league that I'm in does it like this...

1pt for every 20 yards passing
1pt for every 10 yards rushing
6pts for every TD

We don't deduct for INT's and fumbles but you also don't get extra points for monster games like 300-400+ yard performances.

Other than that your scoring is almost the same as mine....we used ESPN for our league.

[WoodysGirl]

Speaking of FoxSports league, anyone not in a league with them should keep it that way. It is by far the worst around.
I agree with this. You're in the same league as me, right, BDC? That was the one Hostile set up.

I'm in Yeager's league on Yahoo and while I don't like that Yahoo doesn't give instant stats, I like their setup so much better.

BigDFan5 wants me to try espn's next year. I was thinking of trying nfl.com's site, tho.

[DaBoys4Life]

I agree with this. You're in the same league as me, right, BDC? That was the one Hostile set up.

I'm in Yeager's league on Yahoo and while I don't like that Yahoo doesn't give instant stats, I like their setup so much better.

BigDFan5 wants me to try espn's next year. I was thinking of trying nfl.com's site, tho.

ESPN is pretty legit with there's I haven't tried NFL.com but I don't think you can go wrong with either one.

[WoodysGirl]

I'm thinking I should've stuck with Brees... Doesn't matter since I'm winning my matchup by 50 pts, but still..

[DaBoys4Life]

I'm thinking I should've stuck with Brees... Doesn't matter since I'm winning my matchup by 50 pts, but still..

Yeah it's crazy seems like Brees was the better choice by half time.

[ajk23az]

Yeah it's crazy seems like Brees was the better choice by half time.

You owe me one of these ":bow: "

:p:


j/k

[DaBoys4Life]

You owe me one of these ":bow: "

:p:


j/k

:lmao2::lmao:

[DaBoys4Life]

Sorry WG Brees is having a monster game.

[masomenos]

37 points in my league so far, lol

[ajk23az]

35.3 points in my league.

[WoodysGirl]

Sorry WG Brees is having a monster game.
I'll never listen to you guys again :D

[DaBoys4Life]

He put up 47 in my league so far...... with Warner scoring 32......

[DaBoys4Life]

I'll never listen to you guys again :D

At least you didn't catch a L.

[Achozen]

I would have lost anyways.

I played against freakin' Michael Turner and I started the Panthers D. :mad:

[DaBoys4Life]

I would have lost anyways.

I played against freakin' Michael Turner and I started the Panthers D. :mad:

Ouch. I had Trent Edwards on my bench =/.

[Achozen]

Ouch. I had Trent Edwards on my bench =/.
Actually, if I would have started Brees and Darren McFadden in place of Warner and Jamal Lewis I would have won...

[DaBoys4Life]

Actually, if I would have started Brees and Darren McFadden in place of Warner and Jamal Lewis I would have won...

Well would have though Dmac would have had 2 TD. I think he had one going into the game nothing you can really do about that.