PDA

View Full Version : post-mock #5

TrueBeliever007
03-20-2010, 12:45 PM
Trade Round 1. pick to Cleveland for there 2nd and 3rd

2a. Nate Allen FS

2b. J.D. Walton C

3a. John Jerry OG

3b. AOA CB

4. Donald Butler ILB

6.Clifton Geathers DL

7.J'Marcus Webb OT

UDFA's
Kelton Tindal WR
Konz
Doug Worthington DE
Aaron Pettrey K

Post your thoughts
RS12
03-20-2010, 01:05 PM
Why would Cleveland give a second and third in a deep draft for a low one, when they need everything?
CanuckCowboysFan
03-20-2010, 01:17 PM
Why would Cleveland give a second and third in a deep draft for a low one, when they need everything?


yepp, lol
dannyboy
03-20-2010, 01:18 PM
Why would Cleveland give a second and third in a deep draft for a low one, when they need everything?

I actually have the same trade(except we get 2, 3 and 5) with Cleveland as they might want Colt McCoy to back up Plummer
Jongb35
03-20-2010, 01:21 PM
Trade Round 1. pick to Cleveland for there 2nd and 3rd

2a. Nate Allen FS

2b. J.D. Walton C

3a. John Jerry OG

3b. AOA CB

4. Donald Butler ILB

6.Clifton Geathers DL

7.J'Marcus Webb OT

UDFA's
Kelton Tindal WR
Konz
Doug Worthington DE
Aaron Pettrey K

Post your thoughts

I don't see any way AOA lasts until the back of round three.
Hostile
03-20-2010, 01:37 PM
I don't see any way AOA lasts until the back of round three.Jason Witten would never make it out of round 1. Stephen Jackson would never be there at 25. Brady Quinn would never be there at 22.

People drop every year.
Jongb35
03-20-2010, 03:35 PM
Jason Witten would never make it out of round 1. Stephen Jackson would never be there at 25. Brady Quinn would never be there at 22.

People drop every year.

You are definitely right, but it is difficult to predict WHICH players are going to drop. If AOA's "consensus value" (if there is such a thing) is in the 2nd round, I wouldn't project him to drop to the back of three.
DFWJC
03-20-2010, 04:04 PM
I actually have the same trade(except we get 2, 3 and 5) with Cleveland as they might want Colt McCoy to back up Plummer
Even a very high 2nd and 3rd is still too much to give up for the 27th pick...let alone that extra 5th rounder. A 2,4 and 5 may do it.

Furthermore, why on earth would they trade all the way up to the 27th slot for player that will very likely be there with the 6th pick in Rd2? I guess if the Redskins don't grab a QB in Rd1, the Browns better move ahead of them in Rd 2 (one slot up) if they want Colt...because he could go to Washington in Rd 2.
Hostile
03-20-2010, 04:53 PM
You are definitely right, but it is difficult to predict WHICH players are going to drop. If AOA's "consensus value" (if there is such a thing) is in the 2nd round, I wouldn't project him to drop to the back of three.Never say never. Guys who you don't expect to drop, do. Guys who you don't expect to rise, do. There is no such thing as set in stone until the transaction is actually made.
TrueBeliever007
03-20-2010, 09:09 PM
Even a very high 2nd and 3rd is still too much to give up for the 27th pick...let alone that extra 5th rounder. A 2,4 and 5 may do it.

Furthermore, why on earth would they trade all the way up to the 27th slot for player that will very likely be there with the 6th pick in Rd2? I guess if the Redskins don't grab a QB in Rd1, the Browns better move ahead of them in Rd 2 (one slot up) if they want Colt...because he could go to Washington in Rd 2.

I saw what cowboyjoe wrote about the point system and i used that i would perfer a fifth and if i was to chose someone it would be marshall newhouse.