Which QB acquisition will have greatest 2011 impact

[DFWJC]

The quarterback musical chairs have been entertaining.
Some are going to start right away, some to start short term, and some may not start at all.

Which Quarterback will have the greatest impact on his new team--measured by improving the team this year?

[SDCowboy85]

None of them will have a real impact. Hasselbeck is older than time. VY, McNabb and Jackson are both horrible. Kolb is mediocre and going to a bad team.

[AmarilloCowboyFan]

None of them will have a real impact. Hasselbeck is older than time. VY and Jackson are both horrible. Kolb is mediocre and going to a bad team.

If Orton ends up in Miami then I'd say him.

[Rynie]

Donovan Mc........bwhahhaha. I couldn't even finish typing that.

[SDCowboy85]

If Orton ends up in Miami then I'd say him.

True, but I'm not sure he will. He just ran the starting offense for Denver today.

[Doomsday101]

Orton in Miami. At least if he ends up in Miami he has a got to guy in Brandon Marshall that he worked well with in Denver

[The30YardSlant]

Orton + Brandon Marshall will be good...again

[JackWagon]

Really depends on where V.Y signs. If he goes to Seattle ... he might do something there.

[LeonDixson]

I'm saying Kolb to the Cards for one reason only. In comparison to what they had last year, he is the only one out of the bunch that represents a clear upgrade IMHO. Although I can't remember who Miami trotted out there last year.

[StanleySpadowski]

Got to be Thigpen to Buffalo. If he can play even mediocre, it's a huge improvement over the QBing the Bills had last year and makes them a competitive team.

[DFWJC]

Got to be Thigpen to Buffalo. If he can play even mediocre, it's a huge improvement over the QBing the Bills had last year and makes them a competitive team.
You think Thigpen can beat our Fitzpatrick? It should be close.

[dewby]

Just noticed the Seahawks picked up Jackson....

Good call.

[RastaRocket]

vince young

[cml750]

I picked Mc Nabb to the Vikings because they have a good team and he is going to impact them in a bad way. If he is the starter they will do bad!!!

[Idgit]

Thank God we've got Tony Romo. What a big bag of suck that list is.

[AmarilloCowboyFan]

Thank God we've got Tony Romo. What a big bag of suck that list is.

:laugh2:

[DFWJC]

I think Tennessee greatly helped themselves with Hasselbeck--who had 7 TDs and 1 int in the playoffs last year (102 passer rating).

Chris Johnson and Kenny Britt and Jared Cook are smiling...compared to having to deal with a rookie QB right away.

Their rookie QB may turn out to be good someday, but he was in no way ready this year. Hasselbeck will teach him to be a pro and give the franchise some short term stabilty.

[Dodger]

What a list...

I don't think any of them will really have that much of an impact this year, but I think, of all of them, Kolb has the best chance of having an impact down the road.

[DFWJC]

I guess Vince can fall into the "other" slot.
He's a backup anyway...though I'm sure he'll get some pt this year.

[JackWagon]

Really like what the Eagles have done ... They are in a really good position with both Vick and VY. I think Vick might actually teach him how to be a pro. Young WRs and RBs. I really like their team. They should win the division.

[Chocolate Lab]

All equal impacts... Nothing?

I guess I'd go with Hasselbeck in Tennessee. I still think he's pretty good, when he can stay healthy. He should be way better than VY or Kerry Collins or whoever else they've been running out there.

[wileedog]

All equal impacts... Nothing?

I guess I'd go with Hasselbeck in Tennessee. I still think he's pretty good, when he can stay healthy. He should be way better than VY or Kerry Collins or whoever else they've been running out there.

Agreed CL. The QB position has been holding that team back for quite a while, and while Hasselback is certainly a bit long in the teeth he is a solid pro.