Sporting News QB Rating

[Martice]

I apolojize if this is a reprint:

Rk. Player Team Prev. Diff. ADP '03 Rk. Comp. Att. Yds. Pass TD Int. Rush

1 Daunte Culpepper MIN 1 0 -- -- 295 454 3479 25 11 4 DAL @PHI CHI
2 Peyton Manning IND 2 0 -- -- 379 566 4267 29 10 0 @NE @TEN GB
3 Michael Vick ATL 3 0 -- -- 50 100 585 4 3 1 @SF STL ARI
4 Matt Hasselbeck SEA 4 0 -- -- 313 513 3841 26 15 2 @NO @TB SF
5 Marc Bulger STL 5 0 -- -- 336 532 3845 22 22 4 ARI @ATL NO
6 Donovan McNabb PHI 6 0 -- -- 275 478 3216 16 11 3 NYG MIN @DET
7 Trent Green KC 7 0 -- -- 330 523 4039 24 12 2 @DEN CAR HOU
8 Aaron Brooks NO 8 0 -- -- 306 518 3546 24 8 2 SEA SF @STL
9 Brett Favre GB 9 0 -- -- 308 471 3361 32 21 0 @CAR CHI @IND
10 Steve McNair TEN 10 0 -- -- 250 400 3215 24 7 4 @MIA IND JAC
11 Tom Brady NE 11 0 -- -- 317 527 3620 23 12 1 IND @ARI BYE
12 Chad Pennington NYJ 12 0 -- -- 189 297 2139 13 12 2 CIN @SD BYE
13 Jeff Garcia CLE 13 0 -- -- 225 392 2704 18 13 7 BAL @DAL @NYG
14 Jake Plummer DEN 14 0 -- -- 189 302 2182 15 7 3 KC @JAC SD
15 Brad Johnson TB 15 0 -- -- 354 570 3811 26 21 0 @WAS SEA @OAK
Rk. Player Team Prev. Diff. ADP '03 Rk. Comp. Att. Yds. Pass TD Int. Rush
16 Jake Delhomme CAR 16 0 -- -- 266 449 3219 19 16 1 GB @KC BYE
17 Rich Gannon OAK 17 0 -- -- 125 225 1274 6 4 0 @PIT BUF TB
18 Tommy Maddox PIT 19 +1 -- -- 298 519 3414 18 17 0 OAK @BAL @MIA
19 Byron Leftwich JAC 20 +1 -- -- 239 418 2819 14 16 2 @BUF DEN @TEN
20 Drew Bledsoe BUF 21 +1 -- -- 274 471 2860 11 12 2 JAC @OAK BYE
21 Mark Brunell WAS 22 +1 -- -- 54 82 484 2 0 1 TB @NYG DAL
22 David Carr HOU 23 +1 -- -- 167 295 2013 9 13 2 SD @DET @KC
23 Quincy Carter DAL 24 +1 -- -- 292 505 3302 17 21 2 @MIN CLE @WAS
24 Carson Palmer CIN 25 +1 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- @NYJ MIA BAL
25 Joey Harrington DET 26 +1 -- -- 309 554 2880 17 22 0 @CHI HOU PHI
26 Eli Manning NYG -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- @PHI WAS CLE
27 A.J. Feeley MIA 27 0 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- TEN @CIN PIT
28 Kerry Collins NYG 18 -10 -- -- 284 500 3110 13 16 0 @PHI WAS CLE
29 Rex Grossman CHI 28 -1 -- -- 38 72 437 2 1 0 DET @GB @MIN
30 Tim Rattay SF 29 -1 -- -- 73 118 856 7 2 0 ATL @NO @SEA
Rk. Player Team Prev. Diff. ADP '03 Rk. Comp. Att. Yds. Pass TD Int. Rush
31 Jon Kitna CIN 30 -1 -- -- 324 520 3591 26 15 0 @NYJ MIA BAL
32 Josh McCown ARI 31 -1 -- -- 95 166 1018 5 6 1 @STL NE @ATL
33 Kyle Boller BAL 32 -1 -- -- 116 224 1260 7 9 0 @CLE PIT @CIN
34 Philip Rivers SD -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- @HOU NYJ @DEN
35 Kurt Warner STL 33 -2 -- -- 38 65 365 1 1 0 ARI @ATL NO
36 Jay Fiedler MIA 34 -2 -- -- 179 314 2138 11 13 3 TEN @CIN PIT
37 Patrick Ramsey WAS 36 -1 -- -- 179 337 2166 14 9 1 TB @NYG DAL
38 Brian Griese TB 37 -1 -- -- 74 130 813 5 6 0 @WAS SEA @OAK
39 Anthony Wright BAL 38 -1 -- -- 94 178 1199 9 8 0 @CLE PIT @CIN
40 Tim Couch CLE 39 -1 -- -- 120 203 1319 7 6 1 BAL @DAL @NYG
41 Ben Roethlisberger PIT -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- OAK @BAL @MIA
42 Drew Brees SD 35 -7 -- -- 205 356 2108 11 15 0 @HOU NYJ @DEN
43 Marques Tuiasosopo OAK 40 -3 -- -- 25 45 324 0 3 0 @PIT BUF TB
44 Gus Frerotte MIN 43 -1 -- -- 38 65 690 7 2 0 DAL @PHI CHI
45 Billy Volek TEN 42 -3 -- -- 44 69 545 4 1 1 @MIA IND JAC
Rk. Player Team Prev. Diff. ADP '03 Rk. Comp. Att. Yds. Pass TD Int. Rush
46 David Garrard JAC 41 -5 -- -- 9 12 86 1 0 0 @BUF DEN @TEN
47 Kelly Holcomb CLE 39 -8 -- -- 193 302 1797 10 12 0 BAL @DAL @NYG
48 Travis Brown BUF 44 -4 -- -- 14 18 160 0 1 0 JAC @OAK BYE
49 Shaun King ARI 37 -12 -- -- 15 22 130 1 1 0 @STL NE @ATL
50 Drew Henson DAL 45 -5 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- @MIN

[Hostile]

Welcome to the forum. Enjoy posting.

Are these fantasy rankings? They must be. Drew Henson has no value to rank 50th at this point. This is a projection on how they think these players will do in 2004? Just guessing....

[jterrell]

Tables can be a challenge. It might be easier to view the source code and get the html formatting.

I can only assume it is a fantasy projection like Hos suggested.

If so I think there ratings are a bit weak. From a Cowboys perspective QC is way too low. I'd put him in the 15 or 17 slot where Gannon and Johnson are. 1 of the 2 probably wont be a starter this season. Maddox may lose his gig as well. Right now QC is basically unchallenged and he does have a guy at WR who catches 80 balls per year.

I'd also move up Kerry Collins quite a few notches.

I'd be very comfortable with QC as my fantasy backup. He'll probably get you about 210 yards per start passing, occasionally score a rushing TD and be at about 1 Td and 1 pick per week.

[Martice]

I have a hard time with Aaron Brooks being ranked so high. Especially when you look who's ranked below him. This has to be a fantasy projection.

Hey Hos, I've had the pleasure in the past of conversating with you. However, it was on the old board and a while ago. Although I don't post often, I do read the threads almost religiously. I've decided to make a determined effort to post more in the name of supporting this forum.

Thanks for welcoming me again and I'll be posting more often than I have in the past.

[big dog cowboy]

With Vick at #3 it's pretty clear those are fantasy rankings/projections.

[Q_the_man]

At least QC is rated higher then Eli who is the #1 pick this year....
:D

[JsnSA]

It has to be a fantasy ranking because Kitna if much better than Q....but won't get to start if he stays with the Bengals.

That has to be why he is ranked that far below Carter.

[TheHustler]

decent fantasy rankings though. i would probably put mcnabb at #3 or #4 though.

[twa]

At least QC is rated higher then Eli who is the #1 pick this year....
:D
Only in peoples fantasy's,sorry couldn't resist ;)

[MichaelWinicki]

At least QC is rated higher then Eli who is the #1 pick this year....
:D


Yep, #23. I'm underwhelmed.

[Sarge]

Yep, #23. I'm underwhelmed.

:D

Morning Michael.