View Full Version : Did Tampa get too cute??
CATCH17
04-27-2012, 12:34 AM
Or did they want Barron all along?
Also.. I think it's weird the Cowboys never interviewed Claiborne.
I wonder if they even knew about his wrist injury.
Im 100% on board with the pick but it seems like all they knew about the guy was based on their film study.
We got a good one today though. I can't believe we got the best defender in the draft.
Bluestang
04-27-2012, 12:36 AM
Or did they want Barron all along?
Also.. I think it's weird the Cowboys never interviewed Claiborne.
I wonder if they even knew about his wrist injury.
Im 100% on board with the pick but it seems like all they knew about the guy was based on their film study.
We got a good one today though. I can't believe we got the best defender in the draft.
Brian Baker did talk to Claiborne at the Combine. He was the only coach to do so.
Scouts had him graded as the best defensive player of the draft and the concensus was at #2 overall on the board.
CATCH17
04-27-2012, 12:38 AM
Brian Baker did talk to Claiborne at the Combine. He was the only coach to do so.
Scouts had him graded as the best defensive player of the draft and the concensus was at #2 overall on the board.
Claiborne said he didn't talk to anyone at anytime that was with the Cowboys.
Bluestang
04-27-2012, 12:40 AM
Claiborne said he didn't talk to anyone at anytime that was with the Cowboys.
I'm not sure who is wrong here but it was reported that Baker did talk to him.
a_minimalist
04-27-2012, 12:42 AM
Def didn't get too cute. They have made some SERIOUS upgrades on their team both in FA and this draft.
Questfor6
04-27-2012, 12:45 AM
I think they got cute & thought STL would take Fletcher Cox like some had projected, but I'd say they crapped their pants when they saw us come up there at 6.
Kangaroo
04-27-2012, 12:48 AM
Or did they want Barron all along?
Also.. I think it's weird the Cowboys never interviewed Claiborne.
I wonder if they even knew about his wrist injury.
Im 100% on board with the pick but it seems like all they knew about the guy was based on their film study.
We got a good one today though. I can't believe we got the best defender in the draft.
I think once they where knocked out of the Trent race for the #3 slot someone made them an offer and they thought it was the smart play so they could still get a player they wanted
johnny utah
04-27-2012, 12:55 AM
I think Tampa tried to get too cute. I also thought that Barron looked very disappointed when the bucs drafted him. Like he expected to go elsewhere. I don't know if anyone else noticed that.
InmanRoshi
04-27-2012, 01:03 AM
If I were a Tampa fan, I would be pretty pissed. Tampa was in position to take one of the no-brainer consensus blue chips, and instead traded down to take a 2nd tier player and what do they have to show for it? A mere 4th round pick? I liked Barron, but he's not Claiborne. Now at CB they got Talib who's one more off the field incident away from a year long suspension and Rhonde Barber who's about a year away from drawing SSI. Then they traded a 2nd and 3rd to move up to get Doug Martin, who is a good player, but is going to be a shared time platoon back, and I just don't draft a RB anywhere in the 1st round unless I think he's going to be an every down work horse, much less trade up for one. Besides, I'm not sure Martin's skillset is really that much different than Blount's.
I would be more concerned about Dallas not interviewing Claiborne if they didn't have close ties with Les Miles that would provide way more insight than a face to face chit chat.
Corleone
04-27-2012, 01:59 AM
I have read and heard all night that Tampa wanted Barron all along and were planning on taking him at #5 but thought they could pick up an extra pick or two in a trade down, which they did. I can't understand why they would rather have Barron and a 4th/7th over Claiborne but that was apparently their guy and they got him and a couple extra picks.
It worked out tremendously for us though.:cool:
Deep_Freeze
04-27-2012, 05:26 AM
If I were a Tampa fan, I would be pretty pissed. Tampa was in position to take one of the no-brainer consensus blue chips, and instead traded down to take a 2nd tier player and what do they have to show for it? A mere 4th round pick? I liked Barron, but he's not Claiborne. Now at CB they got Talib who's one more off the field incident away from a year long suspension and Rhonde Barber who's about a year away from drawing SSI. Then they traded a 2nd and 3rd to move up to get Doug Martin, who is a good player, but is going to be a shared time platoon back, and I just don't draft a RB anywhere in the 1st round unless I think he's going to be an every down work horse, much less trade up for one. Besides, I'm not sure Martin's skillset is really that much different than Blount's.
I would be more concerned about Dallas not interviewing Claiborne if they didn't have close ties with Les Miles that would provide way more insight than a face to face chit chat.
Well Martin is more of a complete back then Blount, Blount is terrible in the passing game and is frequently pulled cause of it. Martin is a good pick for them and could mean Blount becomes a backup.
As for did Tampa get too cute, it will be hard to tell cause they will spin it in order to look good from their end. They have been connected to Claiborne for forever so for them not to get him, they do have to spin it since Barron did look like a reach cause everyone and their mom knew they needed a DB.
They needed both a safety and a CB, so it works out either way for them, even though Morris is the much higher rated prospect at a more premium position. Both positions are hard to fill, especially this year, but in retrospect we are sure lucky we went ahead and traded up cause cause we probably would've ended up with Brockers.
Thats enough to make me do backflips for Mo.
JBell523
04-27-2012, 07:16 AM
It's just puzzling to me that TB didn't want Claiborne.
They hired LSU's DB Coach in the off-season, so they had all the inside info they needed to evaluate Claiborne. And they passed on him.
It's hard for me to believe that they would risk losing out on their guy for an extra 4th rounder. Barron had to have been their guy all along.
jswalker1981
04-27-2012, 07:18 AM
It's just puzzling to me that TB didn't want Claiborne.
They hired LSU's DB Coach in the off-season, so they had all the inside info they needed to evaluate Claiborne. And they passed on him.
It's hard for me to believe that they would risk losing out on their guy for an extra 4th rounder. Barron had to have been their guy all along.
I think they wanted Claiborne, but also liked Barron a lot too. I just think they got a little too cute, and if they wanted Claiborne, should have just taken him. And I'm sure that's why they took Barron where they did. No need to get cute again and trade down, just take him and look to make moves later in the round.
Chocolate Lab
04-27-2012, 07:21 AM
If I were a Tampa fan, I would be pretty pissed. Tampa was in position to take one of the no-brainer consensus blue chips, and instead traded down to take a 2nd tier player and what do they have to show for it? A mere 4th round pick? I liked Barron, but he's not Claiborne. Now at CB they got Talib who's one more off the field incident away from a year long suspension and Rhonde Barber who's about a year away from drawing SSI. Then they traded a 2nd and 3rd to move up to get Doug Martin, who is a good player, but is going to be a shared time platoon back, and I just don't draft a RB anywhere in the 1st round unless I think he's going to be an every down work horse, much less trade up fo
No doubt. All that for a safety and a specialty RB?
Rough times to be an NFL fan in Florida. All three teams are total disasters.
cowboysooner
04-27-2012, 07:32 AM
He was not only the last of the blue chips, he was the last of the blue chips at a huge position of need. Barron is a fine player and even if he turns out to be Brian Dawkins that was a perplexing trade.
There are 3 divisions where you need to be loaded in the secondary and the NFC South is the one with the best tight ends so I guess.
Teague31
04-27-2012, 07:56 AM
i think the rams got too cute as well and ended up missing out on both of the elite receivers.
InmanRoshi
04-27-2012, 08:08 AM
i think the rams got too cute as well and ended up missing out on both of the elite receivers.
Reportedly they would have taken Brockers with the 6th pick had they not been able to trade down, so Im not sure they really even wanted the WRs. They gave a life long defensive coach complete control of the franchise, so he's going to put priority on the defense.
Kangaroo
04-27-2012, 08:24 AM
Reportedly they would have taken Brockers with the 6th pick had they not been able to trade down, so Im not sure they really even wanted the WRs. They gave a life long defensive coach complete control of the franchise, so he's going to put priority on the defense.
I can already tell you the offense they are going to use next year under fisher so they do not need no stinking WR
Run, run, run, run some more ok now pass run run pass run run run run :wink3:
Sam I Am
04-27-2012, 08:40 AM
Claiborne said he didn't talk to anyone at anytime that was with the Cowboys.
I'm not sure who is wrong here but it was reported that Baker did talk to him.
Maybe Claiborne didn't know Baker was a Cowboys coach! I mean, he can't read or that's what his Wonderlic score suggests anyhow. :laugh2:
JackWagon
04-27-2012, 08:53 AM
The Bucs looked stupid unless Barron turns into Reed or Polymalu which i dont think is gonna happen.
DFWJC
04-27-2012, 10:01 AM
i think the rams got too cute as well and ended up missing out on both of the elite receivers.
It's a deep draft for WRs.
DFWJC
04-27-2012, 10:04 AM
Or did they want Barron all along?
Also.. I think it's weird the Cowboys never interviewed Claiborne.
I wonder if they even knew about his wrist injury.
Im 100% on board with the pick but it seems like all they knew about the guy was based on their film study.
We got a good one today though. I can't believe we got the best defender in the draft.
The Bucs GM said they were going to take Barron at 5!
He said he thought he could still get Barron and drop down a couple of slots, but that he got nervous when Dallas moved up to 6. He actually thought we moved up to take Barron.
So, right or wrong, they felt they got exaclty who they wanted and grabbed an extra pick in the process.
Chocolate Lab
04-27-2012, 10:06 AM
i think the rams got too cute as well and ended up missing out on both of the elite receivers.
I was just reading the stltoday.com site to see what they were thinking about the trade, and apparently they really liked Blackmon, but didn't like Floyd so much. They claim that the guy they really wanted was Jenkins, who went to the Niners. The main writer there claimed they didn't have him too far behind Blackmon. Kind of interesting.
I bet there's a run on WRs soon with several teams needing one.
vBulletin® v3.6.4, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.