PDA

View Full Version : OT: Top Running backs


dmq
06-28-2004, 11:52 AM
I just found it interesting how low Clinton Portis was. Where is T-ham, the Raiders savior! Man, that guy gets no love!



Where's the respect?
Chargers' on-field ineptness shoves Tomlinson out of the spotlight





LaDainian Tomlinson is the only player to catch 100 passes and rush for 1,000 yards in the same season.
Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

Running Back Rankings
No. Player Team Points
1. LaDainian Tomlinson S.D. 228
2. Priest Holmes K.C. 224.5
3. Ahman Green G.B. 207.5
4. Shaun Alexander Sea. 180.5
5. Jamal Lewis Bal. 172.5
6. Deuce McAllister N.O. 162.5
7. Fred Taylor Jac. 158
8. Clinton Portis Den. 149
9. Ricky Williams Mia. 135.5
10. Tiki Barber NYG 123
11. Edgerrin James Ind. 120.5
12. Travis Henry Buf. 111
13. Curtis Martin NYJ 94.5
14. Stephen Davis Car. 93.5
15. Domanick Davis Hou. 87.5
16. Eddie George Ten. 64
• Click here for explanation of how totals were derived.




There are many variables in determining the NFL's best all-around running back. It's an exercise in futility. Still the argument rages: Who is the best?

Look no further than LaDainian Tomlinson. Forget the Chargers' 4-12 record, the first pick in the draft (again) and all the other undesirables associated with San Diego. Tomlinson is, even if by the slightest of margins, the league's best all-around running back.

That fact should rankle those who contend San Diego "lost" in the deal after the Chargers traded the No. 1 pick in 2001 to Atlanta, which drafted Michael Vick. San Diego did not come out on the short end of the stick in that deal; Vick is not the league's premier quarterback -- but Tomlinson is the NFL's top running back.

Last season, Tomlinson was one of six running backs to rush for at least 1,500 yards, eclipsing the record of four established in 1979 and equaled in 2002. Yet despite playing behind a suspect offensive line, Tomlinson still managed to account for 46 percent of the Chargers' offense. His 18 touchdowns (13 rushing, four receiving, one passing) were 47 percent of the team's total.

Tomlinson has racked up 4,542 offensive yards the past two seasons, even after being held last year to two of the three lowest single-game totals in his career, 29 and 34 yards.

Yet he still cannot crack the American consciousness, much less a Pro Bowl roster.

"That just shows you what kind of respect we [the Chargers] have around the NFL, which is none," Tomlinson said of being snubbed last season. "If we want some, we've got to earn it ourselves. We've got to flat out, hands down, be better than other guys in stats. That's the way it's always going to be."

If that's the case -- being "better than other guys in stats" -- Tomlinson should have been the first back booking a flight to Hawaii. A look at Tomlinson's 2003 statistics in 17 categories reveals that he is overall the best of the best. Better than Priest Holmes. And Jamal Lewis. And any other running back by comparison.

"That No. 21 that San Diego has is the best I've seen in a long time. ... He's unbelievable," said Denver head coach Mike Shanahan. And CBS analyst Solomon Wilcots told The San Diego Union-Tribune, "L.T. reminds me of Barry Sanders with great footwork, great quickness and great stop-and-start ability."

So why doesn't Tomlinson get the credit he obviously deserves? Is it because he plays on the left coast, in games that generally are not "national" or prime time? Is it because he plays for a team that is just 17-31 in his three seasons? Is it because he doesn't seek the national spotlight to mug for paparazzi or Madison Avenue? Whatever the excuse, it's unacceptable.

However, word is getting around about Tomlinson. He garnered 21 All-Pro votes in The Associated Press balloting last year (one less than Holmes) -- up from four in 2002 (which was three fewer than Fred Beasley). And Sports Illustrated's Dr. Z tabbed Tomlinson as his all-pro back, saying: "No one combines pass catching and running as well as the Chargers' LaDainian Tomlinson does."

Still smarting after Tomlinson's omission from the Pro Bowl, Chargers head coach Marty Schottenheimer said, "I think he's the best running back in the National Football League. It's very, very disappointing when you see the quality of performance he has produced, in every regard.

"I've had players that have been overlooked in the past, but never one that I thought was as obvious as this one should have been."

Indeed, Tomlinson is the league's best all-around running back. And if stats make the back, here is something to think about: Tomlinson has rushed for 4,564 yards -- 351 more than all-time leading rusher Emmitt Smith had in his first three seasons. Tomlinson is 491 yards off Jim Brown's pace through 48 games, and 17 behind Walter Payton's.

Smith, Payton and Brown are the last three men to be the league's all-time leading rusher, so Tomlinson is in good company just three years into his burgeoning career.

The numbers support the case that LaDainian Tomlinson is the NFL's best running back -- and well on his way to becoming one of the game's all-time greats.


B. Duane Cross is a senior producer for SI.com.

TheHustler
06-28-2004, 11:57 AM
decent rankings. i dont necessarily disagree with how low portis is. i think by the end of this coming season, people will see a lot of his succcess had to do with Denver's Oline and run schemes. that is not to say he's not a very good RB, he'd probly be a top 10 RB no matter where he played.

BrownSugar
06-28-2004, 12:00 PM
I wonder when Tomlinson's contract is going to be up...I wish he could go to a better team, otherwise he'll probably end up like Barry Sanders...wanting to quit before his time is really up.

TheKey
06-28-2004, 12:04 PM
Next year BrownSugar,

Portis should be lower now because that was written when he was till with Denver.

All About the D
06-28-2004, 02:36 PM
Lewis definatly needs a higher spot. I don't care what Jamal's catch ratio is he rushed for 2066 yards. !2066! But hey lets get tech. This list boasts about L.T.'s 100 catches and grand rush yards, so I assume that was a big part of this calculation (the link to explanation does not work). Check out the "top ten list" yards gained with those catches.

Rushing+Catch yards
LaDainian Tomlinson 2370
Priest Holmes 2110
Ahman Green 2250
Shaun Alexander 1730
Jamal Lewis 2271
Deuce McAllister 2157
Fred Taylor 1942
Clinton Portis 1905
Ricky Williams 1723
Tiki Barber 1677

L.T. still commands (and it is ridiculous he didn't make Pro Bowl) but Jamal would be #2. Besides that I would rather have a hard core rusher than a combo. Plus, BESIDES THAT Julius is going to dominate everyone with the most mind blowing rookie season in history

joseephuss
06-28-2004, 02:51 PM
I think L.T. is a hard core rusher. He is just stuck behind a below average line, so they have to throw him the ball to get him some more effective touches. They need to find ways to get him the ball without being caught behind the line of scrimmage. They also had to play from behind, so his rushing opportunities went down. The better the team becomes(if they do improve), the less catches he will get and the more carries he will get.


I think Jamal Lewis can improve his receiving stats if the Ravens improve their quarterback play.