Where do you rank Tony Romo out of the 32 starting QBs in the league?

[Lazyking]

Yes, I know another Romo thread but this one, i just wanna know where people rank Tony.. the talk around here some super romo fans talk about him like he's best in the league while others talk like he's the worst.

I'll go on record and say that at this very moment taking in all factors, Romo is about the 7th to 10th best QB in the league. I'm putting him ahead of rookies, untested QBs and scrubs that don't deserve a QB job and just below the elite tier.

To me he's around the Ryan, Flacco, Schraub range..

While his bad games drop him out of the elite tier, the guys below him haven't been as good as he's been for as long as he's been a starter..


i just wanna get a consensus.. and also ask a question, are there ten in their prime QB's you'd rather have then Tony?

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

He's definitely top 5 to me. I'd put Rodgers, Brady, and Brees over him.

[Lazyking]

Originally Posted by Cowboys&LakersFan

He's definitely top 5 to me. I'd put Rodgers, Brady, and Brees over him.

i have them, both Mannings and Big Ben ahead of him, the rest of the top ten are close.. Peyton may have fallen off but I'm giving him a slight pass for the injury right now. Eli is clutch is Big Ben the same I feel.

[dwarecwby311]

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Matt Ryan

5. Eli Manning

6. Tony Romo

[Supercowboy1986]

Originally Posted by dwarecwby311

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Matt Ryan

5. Eli Manning

6. Tony Romo

no WAY i would put peyton ahead of romo, he's been pretty bad. its clear he is not the same peyton, but people want to get him too much credit

[DMAC]

Originally Posted by Supercowboy1986

no WAY i would put peyton ahead of romo, he's been pretty bad. its clear he is not the same peyton, but people want to get him too much credit

Missed an entire year, and neck surgery, and in his 4th game back has already surpassed Romo. I'd take Peyton any day over Tony, and so would 90% of GM's.

[the_h0wey]

Originally Posted by Supercowboy1986

no WAY i would put peyton ahead of romo, he's been pretty bad. its clear he is not the same peyton, but people want to get him too much credit

Peyton has had 1 bad quarter this year, other than that he has not thrown a single pick.

[DMAC]

10 to 12. Not to bad out of 32, but we want number 1 for the Cowboy QB!

[5Stars]

Drew Brees's Saints are 0-4...

If he is so good, why is he better than Romo?

See, this is what fools don't understand. It's a team game, not a one man show.

Rodger's team is 2-2, same as Romo at this point in time.

Yeah, yeah, they won a SB. But, they did not do it all by their self...they had a team that helped.

Anyway, yeah, Romo sucks and will suck until he has someone else to help him.

[kirkjrk]

Originally Posted by DMAC

10 to 12. Not to bad out of 32, but we want number 1 for the Cowboy QB!

Agree, to many over rate him

[RoyTheHammer]

Originally Posted by dwarecwby311

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Matt Ryan

5. Eli Manning

6. Tony Romo

Temporary mind loss.. its gotta be.

Romo over Peyton?

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Originally Posted by RoyTheHammer

Temporary mind loss.. its gotta be.

Romo over Peyton?

Peyton hasn't looked any better than Romo this year. Hell he hasn't really looked good in two years.

[CanadianCowboysFan]

Originally Posted by dwarecwby311

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Matt Ryan

5. Eli Manning

6. Tony Romo

Ryan has never won a playoff game so he can't by definition be top 5.

[DallasJ7]

1. Ryan Tannehill
2. Ryan Fitzpatrick
3. Ryan, Matt
4. Andy Dalton
5. Andy Luck
6. Manning, Eli
7. Manning, Peyton
8. Michael Vick
9. Jake Locker
10. Tony Romo

[bigdnlaca]

Originally Posted by CanadianCowboysFan

Ryan has never won a playoff game so he can't by definition be top 5.

Yeah, I can't understand how Ryan is soooo high on anyone's list at this moment. He is getting up there but I think other qbs would of done better than score 0 points on offense in a playoff game w/ 1 all pro WR, 1 potential probowler @ WR, 1 HoF TE, and a former probowl RB on your team.


Part of his failures could be the system so I don't think Ryan can be rated top 5 until we see how his team finishes.