Quote:
|
Originally Posted by KDWilliams85
[/b]You describe aspirations, not expectations.
Irrationality stems from one's lack of clairvoyance. At this point, any circumstance is an assumption governed by wishful thinking rather than an aspiration governed by present events.
|
I suggest you take a look at something written by David Burns or others in regards to effective communication and cogitive distortions. I'd also suggest you review some of the definitions of the words you've chosen.
Irrationality does not stem from a lack of clairvoyance. First of all no one is clairvoyant in general. Perhaps there are a few people who can see the future but I'd have to say from a medical standpoint that's generally used in movies in a willing suspension of disbelief.
Believing one can see the future and tell what someone else is thinking or feeling or going to do is the cognitive distortion called mind reading.
Irrationality is a belief not based on what would be considered by most people as reasonable or one derived from a lack of "normal" mental clarity.
Having an opinion or even desire to see the team do well is normal activity for a football fan; or a fan of anything. Or it's just a healthy desire to see someone do well; such as believing your son will do well in school this year. That's not clairvoyance but merely human desire expressed in a healthy fashion.
I have no idea what you mean by your second sentence. The sentence structuce seems proper but your choice of words leaves me having to assume you mean thinking the team will do well is wishful thinking. I think most knowledgable fans would recognize the teams general place in the overall power structure of the NFL and understand they cannot predict the future with any certainty. However most generally get the relative odds of success and failure in the ballpark. Expressing views in this forum is a healthy activity overall. Perhaps some of us spend a little too much time here but I don't presume to know that or judge anyone on that basis. And of course many of us are here because we are fans of the Cowboys and want to believe they will be successful. And we will be disappointed if they are not. Taking this too seriously is not healthy but it's still a normal hobby as long as it does not disrupt the life of the fan or others.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by KDWilliams85
I don't expect anyone to hold an opinion similiar to mine. However, I do aspire for someone to share the same view as me.
|
As a judgmental statement it appears you think others opinions are not as relatively accurate and important as yours. I could be wrong but it certainly appears that way.
If you would present your credentials as an expert on football as well as having inside information perhaps I would entertain the notion of viewing some of your opinions in higher regard that the vast majority of others on this forum when they contain information not readily available to the rest of us. There are a few people here who do have inside information and there are some very knowlegable football people here including former players and current coaches. Otherwise I will value your opinion on an equal basis with others.
For you to aspire others share your same view is not unheathly but it appears your desire is excessive. Again that is a judgmental statement that could easily be wrong. Only you can be the judge of that.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by KDWilliams85
Perhaps if I called anyone specific stupid. However, I did not address anyone in such a manner. I addressed the very idea as stupid.
|
You did address people here in general so you did imply some were stupid for basing their beliefs on a value system different from yours. This is the cognitive distortion of labeling and I stand by my initial statement.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by KDWilliams85
You're a hypocrite for saying that. To be critical of my view makes you as narcissistic as you claim me to be. And by making that assumption, it makes your take on the subject irrational. Since it is your opinion of such, I won't demean you by saying it isn't valid. But, I will say it is quite worthless.
|
Those are valid points. Labeling me as a hypocrite is one way it appears to me you are having problems with others here on this forum. My last statement and intial statement were made in a constructive manner and this entire lengthy discussion is meant to be constuctive. It is time consuming on my part and certainly boring to others IMO. I am worried that not doing this thru a PM makes me appear to be "smacking" you and that would be a valid view from your standpoint IMO. Again it is meant as contructive. There are others who may benefit if they will from this discussion. However, any further communication along these lines will be done if at all by me via PMs to you.
And you are welcome to PM me anytime like anyone else as long as conversations are civil, cordial and courteous.