Mcnabb Is Not This Great Qb - Dallas Cowboys Forum

dargonking999 · 02-06-2005

I mean look at this moron in the biggest game of hislife sittin here throwin 2 INT's horrible passes jsut floating crap out there. He as overthrown reciver after reciver, and if it wasnt for andy ried he woulda gave up the ball in the begging.

MCNABB=Sorry QB

KWilliamsAWinfield · 02-06-2005

I always say that Mcnabb always throw at people's ankles *Laughing*

BlueStar22 · 02-06-2005

I'd love it if he wore a Star on his helmet. That's the bottom line.

KWilliamsAWinfield · 02-06-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlueStar22

I'd love it if he wore a Star on his helmet. That's the bottom line.

Of course, Vinny is the worst Quarterback the Cowboys ever had

BlueStar22 · 02-06-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by RandyMoss84

Of course, Vinny is the worst Quarterback the Cowboys ever had

uh, no! the young man is maturing into a great QB.

Woods · 02-06-2005

Shoot, McNabb leads them to a TD . . . . I can't believe Pinkston actually stepping up

Wolverine · 02-06-2005

McNabb is a good QB but he will never even be close to a great QB. If he didnt have his runnin ability he woulda never even made it as a starter for a college team. Take away McNabbs mobility and he makes Vinny look like a Pro Bowler.

dargonking999 · 02-06-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by Woods

Shoot, McNabb leads them to a TD . . . . I can't believe Pinkston actually stepping up

no he threw the ball down the field and asked god to let soembody catch it thats wearing green

BlueStar22 · 02-06-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wolverine

McNabb is a good QB but he will never even be close to a great QB. If he didnt have his runnin ability he woulda never even made it as a starter for a college team. Take away McNabbs mobility and he makes Vinny look like a Pro Bowler.

ooooook. Funny that he doesn't run as much as he did when he first came into the league and look at the guy. I know how we all feel about Philly but give the guy some credit. Good QB's don't get you to the NFC Title game 4 years in a row, especially with the help he had around him before this year.

dargonking999 · 02-06-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlueStar22

ooooook. Funny that he doesn't run as much as he did when he first came into the league and look at the guy. I know how we all feel about Philly but give the guy some credit. Good QB's don't get you to the NFC Title game 4 years in a row, especially with the help he had around him before this year.

yes a good QB can, great QB's leads teams to superbowls, Mcnabb couldnt do anything against teams that were better than them, he goes against a defense worth of a name and he gets put in his place.(i.e steelers, 2nd game against the cowboys) when Mcnabb can play like an NFL QB against an actauly NFL defense then he can be nameda great QB

Hoods · 02-06-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wolverine

McNabb is a good QB but he will never even be close to a great QB. If he didnt have his runnin ability he woulda never even made it as a starter for a college team. Take away McNabbs mobility and he makes Vinny look like a Pro Bowler.

Although I agree that McNabb is overrated, I don't think you can say "if he didn't have his running ability" and use that as an argument. That's like saying if Barry Sanders didn't have his moves he'd be a bad running back.. Obviously. However, what makes them good is the talent they have and their versatility.

Vick isn't the highest paid QB because he sits in the pocket you know..