seeking thoughts on which is the better value

[Cowboy from New York]

Just throwing some thoughts out here to see what you guys think about some draft scenarios and which ones appeal to you the most/least or if they are just too dang unrealistic.
Which is the better value?
1. Troy Williamson at pick #20 or
Roddy White falling to our 2nd rounder?

2. Marcus Spears at 20 or
Alex Barron, at the same spot?

3. Shane Merriman at 11
or Mike Williams?

4. Channing Crowder at #20 or
Kevin Burnett in the 2nd?

5. Derrick Johnson at #11 or
trade down with the Saints for #16 and
their 3rd rounder(#80)?

Let me know what ya think!

[silverbear]

Originally Posted by Cowboy from New York

Just throwing some thoughts out here to see what you guys think about some draft scenarios and which ones appeal to you the most/least or if they are just too dang unrealistic.
Which is the better value?

1. Troy Williamson at pick #20 or
Roddy White falling to our 2nd rounder?

Neither... trade down at 20, pick up a 3rd round pick, then draft Matt Jones in the 3rd... or Terrence Murphy...

2. Marcus Spears at 20 or
Alex Barron, at the same spot?

Spears, if those are the only 2 options... I wonder if Marcus will still be there at 20, though...

3. Shane Merriman at 11
or Mike Williams?

Shawne Merriman, please...

4. Channing Crowder at #20 or
Kevin Burnett in the 2nd?

Neither... go for Daryl Blackstock in the 2nd instead...

5. Derrick Johnson at #11 or
trade down with the Saints for #16 and
their 3rd rounder(#80)?

DJ, all the way...

[Cowboy from New York]

Matt Jones seems to have a lot of potential but a 3rd seems high for a guy who never played wideout before. Probably would contribute very little for a season or two.

[jswalker1981]

Originally Posted by Cowboy from New York

Matt Jones seems to have a lot of potential but a 3rd seems high for a guy who never played wideout before. Probably would contribute very little for a season or two.

I like the guy. Players like that offer so much when it comes to play calling. All the different things they can do makes it almost impossible to defend. A third does sound too high, I wouldn't mind him in the fifth or later. Also, I would love to get DJ at 11, and Pollack at 20. 3-4 D includes DJ, Dat, Thornton/James, and Pollack at LB, Glover, Fergy, and Ellis on the D-line. 4-3 has DJ, Dat, Thornton/James, D-line has Pollack, Glover, Fergy, and Ellis.