Rate the QB by career TD-to-INT numbers

[gimmesix]

Originally Posted by LUVDABOYS

334-123
324-165
436-209
177-91

not really interested after that

Just based on these numbers, that's a pretty good choice. I'd have 436-209 (Peyton Manning) on top, followed by 334-123 (Tom Brady).

[gimmesix]

First of all, I created this thread because of the one about John Elway in the Newszone. I didn't do it to prove that one QB is better than another simply to show our perceptions of these QB's career sometimes don't reflect the reality of the numbers.

Here are the QBs listed:

300-226 John Elway

191-108 Be Roethlisberger

211-149 Eli Manning

334-123 Tom Brady

324-165 Drew Brees

177-91 Tony Romo

208-128 Kurt Warner

141-90 Troy Aikman

436-209 Peyton Manning

153-109 Roger Staubach

Were any of these a surprise?

[5Stars]

Originally Posted by Rack Bauer

I'll rate those QBs when you tell me how good their supporting cast is/was.

DId they have a defense that gave them short fields from time to time?

Did they have an offensive line that could run the football?

Did they have an offensive line that could consistently give them QB time to throw?

Sounds like you are talking about the Cowboys!

[dogberry]

Great, looks like I wouldn't have drafted Brady either.

I didn't get into honors second grade math.

2.69 in the cloud forever.

[TwoDeep3]

Stats, the legal tender of the people on the losing end.