2013 Mel Kiper Jr. Invitational Report Card....

[tm1119]

Still think I got robbed with my grade. I got 2 of the highest potential guys in the entire draft in Mingo and Watson. And Slay and Bostic in the 4th are 2 talented guys at positions of need who could challenge for starting spots right away. Not saying I deserve an A because i shouldn't have made that trade, but in the end I got talent. A solid C/C+ is what I would give myself.

[DFWJC]

Originally Posted by tm1119

Still think I got robbed with my grade. I got 2 of the highest potential guys in the entire draft in Mingo and Watson. And Slay and Bostic in the 4th are 2 talented guys at positions of need who could challenge for starting spots right away. Not saying I deserve an A because i shouldn't have made that trade, but in the end I got talent. A solid C/C+ is what I would give myself.

It says you highest grade was a 6.
I gave you a 6.5 (or at least that's what my spreadsheet says)
Maybe they dropped the 1/2 pt

[xwalker]

Originally Posted by tm1119

Still think I got robbed with my grade. I got 2 of the highest potential guys in the entire draft in Mingo and Watson. And Slay and Bostic in the 4th are 2 talented guys at positions of need who could challenge for starting spots right away. Not saying I deserve an A because i shouldn't have made that trade, but in the end I got talent. A solid C/C+ is what I would give myself.

You can't minimize giving up a 2014 3rd round pick.

Look at supercowboy8 who gave up a 2014 3rd also, but he ended up with and extra 1st rounder in 2013. Even obtaining the extra 1st rounder, he still ranked 20th.

[DFWJC]

Originally Posted by xwalker

You can't minimize giving up a 2014 3rd round pick.

Look at supercowboy8 who gave up a 2014 3rd also, but he ended up with and extra 1st rounder in 2013. Even obtaining the extra 1st rounder, he still ranked 20th.

Did you run the numbers on his trade using a trade value chart?

I thought I recall seeing his trade was actually fair.
If so, then there is no ground to stand on in criticizing his trade.

But maybe I am mixing up his trade with a different one. I'm not sure.

[Risen Star]

Originally Posted by DFWJC

It says you highest grade was a 6.
I gave you a 6.5 (or at least that's what my spreadsheet says)
Maybe they dropped the 1/2 pt

You gave him a 6 in the grades you sent me.

[DFWJC]

Originally Posted by Risen Star

You gave him a 6 in the grades you sent me.

Must have dropped the decimals.
So i was his highest. 6. Not so good.

[Risen Star]

Originally Posted by DFWJC

Must have dropped the decimals.
So i was his highest. 6. Not so good.

He got a bunch of 6s. 6 to be exact.

You gave Atlanta an 8.5 and Tampa Bay a 9.5. Those were the only decimals.

[Tezz]

I thought the Patriots got 3 impact players that fit their roster...

Regarding the Ravens, trade aside I like my draft and will stand by it through thick and thin! haha

[AsthmaField]

I love the Tampa Bay draft. The first 4 players are very good for where they were picked IMO.