Originally Posted by Bob Sacamano
there's too much going for Porter to not be taken w/in the 1st 2 rounds
he has some things that you just can't teach
btw, what do you think of me list?
He's also missing a lot of things that you can't teach though. I'm sure he will be drafted Rd 2 though, I just wouldn't be the one do it.
This is how I have your list rated:
For reference Terrence Newman would have been a 7.0 and Anthony Henry would have been a 5.0. Now there's no real cap on what a players score can be, but to see something over 6 or even 5 is pretty rare. I won't get into full detail of the formula but its based on both college production and the combine. Even half a point is a pretty substantial difference in this system though. So as far as the players you have listed I would rank them like
1. Cromartie - Talent Level: Early Round 1
2a. Cason - Talent Level: Late Round 1/Early Round 2
2b. Talib - Talent Level: Late Round 1/Early Round 2
3. McKelvin - Talent Level: Late Round 2/Early Round 3
4. Porter -Talent Level: Round 3
5. Lee - Talent Level: Round 4
6. Jenkins - Talent Level: Late Round 4/Early Round 5
I'm still working with the Talent Levels a little bit but that's around where I'll have the final levels, give or take a half a round or so.