Originally Posted by SDCowboy85
Because of the stupid stigma that Super Bowls are all on the QB.
Fouts, Marino, and Moon all made it in without a superbowl victory -- Fouts and Moon didn't even make it to a Superbowl.
All of them, however, played a ton of playoff games and won a lot more than the 1 playoff game Romo has won.
In summary: You can be a HOF QB without a Superbowl appearance -- but you need a heck of a lot more post-season success than 1 playoff victory.