In your UNBIASED opinion, do you think this is a good trade

[supertitan17]

pretend you're not a Cowboy fan

[jumanji]

your 3rd post on this - let it go

[ABQCOWBOY]

I think it was a great trade for the Cowboys. They got a 1st in 2005 and they took two very good players that are at need positions. I don't really see the down side here.

[chinch]

it was not a sexy move, but the trade was a no-brainer tilted in our favor

[supertitan17]

sorry, I didn't know you could reply before making the poll

I would have made it quicker if I had known

[jkbear11]

I think it was very good deal! we might have really high 1st round pick...

but i am disappointed that we passed on KJ and SJ.... o well....

Trust Tuna!!!

[InmanRoshi]

It might be one thing if either of these runningbacks at #22 were great, sure-fire, can't miss RB's ... but I don't think either of them were (they certainly weren't coveted by teams like great RB's are). I think every RB in the draft has their own unique flaws and strengths, and the Cowboys found the back they felt best fit what they want to do.

[BadKarma]

...initially, I thought it was a sh*tty deal, considering we passed up on SJ and KJ. But after regaining my senses - getting another second, a fifth and Buffalo's 1st next year - yeah, that's acceptable.

S

[supertitan17]

It's only a good deal if Buffalo wins less than 6 games this year

[Nerm]

Originally Posted by supertitan17

pretend you're not a Cowboy fan

Over on extremeskins they were sh(!!)ting bricks over what the boys got in the trade. They are not Cowboy fans. Of course some of them are waiting to hear (from a few posters there) why this is the worst trade in NFL history.


I wanted SJ bad, but you have to take that trade. I think its a good deal.

[da_boyz_mk]

if next years no. 1 from buffalo is a top 12 pick then it is an outstanding deal for us. also it depends on how jones develops.

[TheHustler]

value wise, its a great trade.

[roy31]

This trade has a lot of what ifs , we will just have to let it play out and see . I also agree that just because SJ and KJ were the best backs in this draft does not make them great backs . This was a very weak runningback draft .