David Carr for Ricky Williams?

[EveryoneElse]

This would be a HUGE steal for Miami. David Carr has everything your looking for in a QB. He's tough as nails, great arm, great accuracy, can move a little. If Houston ever gets that guy an O-line and a decent running game, LOOK OUT.

Miami could give them Ricky,their 2nd, and a 3rd and still come out better in the deal.

David Carr > Ricky Williams, 2nd and 3rd round picks

Houston would be crazy to do this.

[koolaid]

i dont think this would be a bad move for houston or miami.
I think carr's days in houston are over, he had his chance and did not perform, granted the o-line was awfull, so he never really got a chance, but i feel like houston has given up on him. With Ricky and Davis could have a 1-2 punch at RB, and they could also draft hometown hero vince young. Upgrade the O-line this offseason and with young, williams, davis, and andre johnson, houston could have a solid O going into next season

[TLW47]

One of the Houston's sports radio guys had a great point.

He said if the Texans do not take Young that every single time Carr makes a bad play, a bad read, throws an interception, whatever bad he does he will be booed.

I don't care about the Texans much at all because their fans hate on the Boys so much but you have to think this guy is as good as done in Houston.

He's had 4 years and done next to nothing with less than nothing to work with. If they draft Bush his butt will really be under the microscope. If they draft Young he's gone.