Originally Posted by Biggems
So if you had to choose between McFadden and Mendenhall, who would you pick.....and why?
I'd take McFadden, but it's not going to be an option for Dallas IMO. The main reason is because McFadden has done it for 2 years in the SEC really with no passing game to speak of. It's really hard for me to pick, but like I said if both were on the board with our pick I'd take McFadden. I'm not sure about how well McFadden holds onto the ball, but early in Mendenhalls career he had some fumble problems. It seems to be corrected now, but I think McFadden has proved he can carry the load moreso then Mendenhall in his career so far.
Like I said earlier though I don't think the talent gap between them is as big as what some might think.