Originally Posted by ChrisFul
Why? What's the point? Anytime i even MENTION his name, the "Apologist! Jock Sniffer!" calls start cascading, and whatever legitimate topic the thread is about gets stomped all to hell in a bash fest and/or personal insults. You cannot mention his name on this board without having it degenerate into a bunch of childish retardedness.
Im glad someone likes what small insight i can bring to our starting QB on this board. Now that i've answered hos..
Im not answering any more stupid posts from stupid fans(you know who you are) in this stupid thread. Feel free to flame me if you wish, no retaliation will be offered.
I am stupid for asking why Hutch isn't given the same chances or excuses of Carter? Where did I ever personally insult anyone? How was anything I posted childish? Anything I have ever said negative towards QC is simply criticism, which I think I am entitled to. I think he has shortcomings as a player.
I will agree bashing comes from both sides. There are extremists on both sides, but also those that have an opinion and try to make reasonable arguments for or against their side. If people give legitimate reasons for their support of carter, I have no issue with it. I do have a problem with the fact that the rules don't seem to apply to him and he is held to a different standard than any other player. I gave, what I believe to be, legitimate reasons earlier in this thread why I don't think Carter has what it takes to be a star. I also pointed out some things I think he does well. I don't think that is "childish retardness".
As far as Hutch, QC is the better QB right now. Hutch has also had less of a chance, but QC beat him fair and square. He does have some talents though and I think it is foolish to toss him on the scrap heap. How about this scenario? Vinny doesn't come in (for whatever reason, there are many). QC gets hurt early. Do you want to take your chances early with Romo and Henson who have yet to take a NFL regular season snap? At least Hutch has played and has been playing in Europe. The idea of team building is to develop your roster top to bottom. Something I think BP has mentioned. Hutch probably won't be anything long term either, but why not develop him while he is on the roster?