Take all the QBs in here. Put them in their prime. Put them in any offense you want with the weapons of that offense. Who starts?
Not a doubt in my mind that John Elway starts and everyone else rides the pine. The only weakness in John Elway's game was the weapons around him. Give him the benefit of the same weapons other people had and he runs away with it.
He had every tool. If QB was made from a mold this guy would be the model.
Interesting side note. At different points in time I have heard Elway, Young, and Marino all say that Staubach was their hero growing up.