[quote=Hostile]
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by jay cee
Uh, because it was a thread about Bledsoe where Aikman was brought up.
|
But it was never a comparison of Aikman and Bledsoe. It was only to point out that even hall of famers will struggle against elite teams when they don't have an elite team around them. Point proven. No amount of your twisting will change that.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hostile
As I have repeatedly pointed out, no. 4-6 at the end of his career does not equate to 15% over an entire career.
|
I never asked you if 4-7 equated to 15%. And you know that. So don't call me out on my opinions if you are going to try and twist what I say.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hostile
Because it doesn't support your thesis. I don't care what the activity is, 40% success rate trumps 15% success rate by a wide gap.
Yet the very years you brought up do not support this. 1996 to 1999 he was 4-6. To even be close to your case study of Bledsoe he would have to be at 2-10.
|
The years I brought up, support my opinion. Not what you want to twist my opinions to be.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hostile
Maybe but history does not support your stance does it? He's been pretty pedestrian for a long time against those elite teams.
|
He's played on some pretty pedestrian teams. I think he wins more if he is on an elite team.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hostile
jay cee, I know you aren't exactly Aikman's biggest fan, (or at least I seem to remember that from previous debates) but on this his record simply destroys the point you were trying to make.
|
Is that what this is all about, because you think I don't like Aikman? I rooted for Aikman his entire career. And will be happy to see him enter the hall of fame. Saying that he lost more against the elite teams when the Cowboys stopped being an elite team was my point. And that is true.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hostile
You're trying to compare a guy who has a dismale record against that criteria to a guy who is one of the top 4 ever in that same criteria. How does that not register?
|
Don't tell me what I am trying to do. I have told you countless times what I was doing. I have no control over how you take it, but I will call you on it when you try and turn it into something else.
How does that not register to you?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hostile
If you used someone else as your litmus test other than Starr, Brady, or Montana it would have made sense. Using Aikman as the control doesn't support your theory, it destroys it. Kaboom.
|
From all of your statements, you are totally off base as to what my litmus test was actually meant to be.