Originally Posted by jksmith269
That would be too hard to answer IMO does E and TD compare to Troy, Roger, and Don? Man that would be a hard choice. but a good RB will always open up your passing game where IMO a good qb doesn't always open up your running game. So I'd prob still go wiith Emmitt and TD.
I agree, that would not be an easy call. Well, to me, QBs are the hardest position to fill. While I can see your line of reasoning, I just think that the NFL is a QB driven league. I personally believe that RBs can change and a team can continue to be succesful, assuming you replace with talent. Not so with QBs. Talented QBs can come in and follow a great QB but they hardly ever succeed. Seems like at least one guy has to die by the sword, regardless, before a new QB can come in and have success. Also, it takes longer to develope a good QB. I'd have to go with QB but again, I'd understand anybody who looked at it differently.