Originally Posted by couchscout
I told a good buddy of mine before the draft that I would trade Romo, Witten, Ware, and a 1st for Luck and not even bat an eyelash. And if I were Indy and received that offer, I'd turn it down flat. I still feel that way today. I have a feeling that Luck is gonna go down as my all time favorite QB, I already take time out of each week to watch his game on Rewind. Watch him anytime you get a chance folks, we're watching greatness.
Are you out of your damn mind? You're talking about one of the greatest pass rushers of all time in DeMarcus Ware, one of the greatest tight ends in Jason Witten, and a terrific albeit struggling quarterback in Tony Romo. You seriously wouldn't trade Luck for that? That's just ridiculous to turn down an offer that includes terrific players like that would without question improve your football team.
Good grief Luck is getting overrated and for what because he beat a couple of bad teams? He beat one good team this season in the Packers, but that was over a month ago when they were struggling. These last few weeks have all been against subpar teams in Cleveland, Tennessee, Miami, and today Jacksonville. Overall on the season Luck has been average at best. Only 10 touchdown passes, 8 picks, and a very mediocre 79 QB rating. He's also completing 56 percent of his passes which is terrible. Not impressed at all.
Give me Robert Griffin III over Luck any day of the week. Griffin has been far better than Luck. 8 touchdown passes to only 3 interceptions. A quarterback rating of 93. He's completing 65 percent of his passes. He also has 6 rushing touchdowns. He's a very versatile quarterback. Not just a runner also a terrific pocket passer.