Sorry Phil I don't agree.
I respect the opinion. He played the position and won a Superbowl so he knows a thing or two about the position of QB in the NFL.
I just don't agree.
I also don't agree that his receivers don't help him. They do, for sure, but he also helps them. It's a two way street.
It's silly to think Eli isn't elite.
The guy owns 2 rings by getting game winning drives in the biggest games of his life. It doesn't hurt either that he just so happened to out duel this guy who is unquestionably elite. You might have heard of him, his name is Tom Brady.
In the biggest game of the year Eli has made the plays to win the game twice, where the Golden Boy couldn't.
Eli is elite.
To say anything else is being completely dishonest.