E-Lie has never been elite, isn't elite, and will never be elite.
He is just too goofy and makes far too many bonehead plays. The bonehead plays are the reason he will never be elite. This clown makes more bonehead plays than Romo. And just because he has gotten away with a lot of them doesnt excuse them or nullify them.
Okay, so he has 2 rings. That 1st SB and that pass play to Tyree was a fluke. Sure he was able to stay up rather than fall down as he was tripping all over his own feet, but anybody that watched that knows it was nothing but a lucky play. Far better QB's who have played far better in the big game have walked away with losses.
Rings dont tell the whole story.
Mark Rypien got a ring and Dan Marino didnt.