Originally Posted by ABQCOWBOY
I can tell you right now that there are several posters on this board that do know enough about the game of football to be able to comment on this. This is not an opinion, this is a fact.
What I would like you to explain, now that you've basically insulted the collective intelligence of the entire board, is how you come to the conclusion that you can make that statement and support it with fact?
If people knew what they think they knew, they'd be in the game
None of us here, or on any MB has any idea what calls are made from play caller to QB, what the checks, what the hot routes are, what the game plan was for certain situations, what the injury situation is like and why a certain player is not being highlighted, etc, which is why I never tend to critique play calling.
To say that people actually know what Andrew Luck is doing compared to RG3 or Russel Wilson is silly. They don't unless they are in those meeting rooms with Luck/Arians, RG3/Kyle Shanahan, etc.
And the posters who have a better idea of the nuances of professional football (CouchScout/AdamJt) aren't pontificating in this debate