FA QB X: 33 yo, league leader in picks. No playoffs in 3 years. Would you sign him?
Let's take the name "Tony Romo" out of it.
Suppose there was another 33-year-old quarterback coming off a year in which he led the league in interceptions. He hasn't been to the playoffs in three years. He has won one playoff game in his entire career.
Would you sign that quarterback to a five-year deal?