Originally Posted by Dave_in-NC
Couldn't playing an injured one armed Ware be just as bad?
What if his shoulder and elbow (that they knew needed surgery)
was injured more severely during the Skins game?
Same thing. You are in a do or die, you play your best players.
No one complained when Emmitt beat the Giants with a separated shoulder,
no one was complaining that he could have been ruined for good.
Just another attempt to make Garrett a world beater.
I think you missed my point. My point is not that Shanahan is wrong. I don't know that he was (though I do think it is a bit different with a 1st year, franchise QB, and A KNEE INJURY)... I used "genius" because that is how some on this board view anyone but Garrett.. but that is an aside...
My point is that no way you would cut Garrett the slack you just cut Shanahan... well, maybe you would, but I can GUARANTEE a HUGE portion of this forum wouldn't. It would be fires and Garrett being hung in effigy