RG3 would've run away with the award had he not screwed up his knee (pun partially intended). But that's the thing. What makes him dangerous is the threat of him ripping off 70 yards on a zone read and the play-action off of the resulting running game. And that's already gotten him concussed and gimped up. The Skins parted with three first rounders to get the guy. I bet we don't see much, if any zone read in DC next season. Unfortunately, Shanny's regular offense (sans the college stuff) is an excellent scheme and RG3's talents are tailor made to make it go.
That said, I would've voted for Luck.