McFadden Watch: 321 Yards on 34 carries

[sjordan6]

You people can say what you want and I am past the whole thing about having a shot at Peterson last draft. The bottom line is Darren McFadden is a stud who is absolutely great! I dont think it fair to compare the two backs but I really dont see major differences in their results. I watched the Razorbacks game this Saturday and was amazed at how fast he is. He has been clocked running the 40 in a 4.35 and has the moves and power of an stud in the making. He will not go past the 3rd pick and I think it would be a steal to give up both #1 picks to get him!

Because let's be honest, Julius and Barber are o.k. but this offense definitely needs the WOW factor.

[03EBZ06]

Originally Posted by sjordan6

Because let's be honest, Julius and Barber are o.k. but this offense definitely needs the WOW factor.

I thought we had WOW factor with Romo, TO, Witten, and Barber on offense.

[Chocolate Lab]

What's really sickening is that at this point, the Pats have a much better chance of drafting him than we do.

From now on, any GM that trades a future #1 to the Pats should be held down and beaten like Pyle in Full Metal Jacket.

[ninja]

If SF keeps losing, NE may just have the 3rd pick in the draft. And SF will keep losing. They are that bad. What an idiotic trade they made with NE just to draft some offensive lineman.

[smarta5150]

I am still not convinced we need a "wow" factor.

If we are gonna get rid of JJ then there are plenty of options at running back in this years draft which we can pull with our current picks.

Our run game has been a great compliment to our potent pass attack thus far.

We are 7-1, top offense in the NFC and we aren't getting the yards like the Packers (we actually have a balance attack).

2 1st round picks equal 2 "stud" needs... not 1 stud "want."

[AbeBeta]

McFadden sucks.

Now I want Jonathon Stewart.

Ok McFadden doesn't suck. But we aren't getting him.

[BARRYRAY]

This is the year we trade 2 for 1 to get an impact guy no more Bobby Carpenter from the mid rounds..

[smarta5150]

Originally Posted by BARRYRAY

This is the year we trade 2 for 1 to get an impact guy no more Bobby Carpenter from the mid rounds..

What # pick was Ware?

[Sam I Am]

Darren McFadden = Herschel Walker

[ZeroClub]

Originally Posted by abersonc

McFadden sucks.

Now I want Jonathon Stewart.

Ok McFadden doesn't suck. But we aren't getting him.

Yup.

The draft is such a crap shoot anyway ... who is to say that the 2nd or 3rd RB taken in the draft won't have a better career?

(That's what I tell myself to feel better about the unexpectedly late Browns draft position)

[Chocolate Lab]

Originally Posted by nyc

Darren McFadden = Herschel Walker

Please tell me you aren't saying that being like Herschel is a negative...

But I think you are.

[Sam I Am]

Originally Posted by Chocolate Lab

Please tell me you aren't saying that being like Herschel is a negative...

But I think you are.

No, I'm just saying he's no Adrian Peterson. Of course, Walker while a very good player, didn't exactly light up the league. By saying that, I mean he isn't worth #1 overall.

[CowboyWay]

Originally Posted by nyc

No, I'm just saying he's no Adrian Peterson. Of course, Walker while a very good player, didn't exactly light up the league. By saying that, I mean he isn't worth #1 overall.

You're crazy. Herschel was all that and more. Go look what he did in the USFL, he spent 3-4 years there, then came to the NFL and split time with Dorsett for a couple more.

If you believe McFadden = Walker, that is a HUGE compliment.

You just don't realize it.

[StanleySpadowski]

I think people overestimate top five/ten draft picks. They simply aren't worth what the present cap figures say they are.

The Rams had a couple of their own top ten picks on their team when they won the Super Bowl but that was thanks to finding a QB working behind a cash register. The Ravens also had two I think and of course Manning went #1 overall but for every one of those, there are tons of Andre Wadsworths and Ryan Leafs.

[Sandyf]

Getting McFadden may be tough but consider a few things,

1) McFadden hasn't been an angel off the field and it will affect his draft status,

2) forget NE getting him because he doesn't fit Bellick style and they have 3 young backs plus the fact that the dear Commissioner said if NE made the playoffs they would lose a 1st round draft pick --- he didn't say which one --- that decision is to be made after the season --- he knew full well that NE had two picks in the first round so they could lose the SF pick

3) You have to take into count what other teams want in the draft, example would be a Houston who still could end up with a top ten pick, they need a Julius Jones type back, a DE and a LB -- so what is to say we don't franchise Jones and trade say Spears, Jones and Carpenter for that pick instead on our 1st round picks. Probably improbable but definitely worth thinking about.

4) Except for Peterson and Bush the last five years haven't been kind to RB being drafted high in the first round and face it except for Peterson and Bush the others have been somewhat of a bust. So even though some think McFaddin is great you have others with similar talent this year like Slaton, Felix Jones, Ray Rice, and others. It is a crap shoot and one teams might not want to shoot for in the top 14 or 15.

A long way to go before the season is over and the draft picks rankings are there. Good discussion but even the combine will make a huge difference to these RBs. If McFaddin runs a 4.5 in the combine, do you really think he will go top ten.