Better Chance to Make Team, Madison or Butler?

[xwalker]

Todd Archer thinks that the Rookies are ahead of Butler.

Cornerback: Tim went with Mario Butler as his fifth cornerback. I’m going with undrafted rookie Isaac Madison, who was working with the first team sub defenses, which means he is ahead of Butler, who spent last year on the practice squad.

Safety: Tim went with five safeties: Gerald Sensabaugh, Brodney Pool, Barry Church, Danny McCray and Matt Johnson. I’m going with four safeties right now and Pool is the odd man out. Again this is fluid and things change, but I’m going with a sixth cornerback and that is undrafted rookie Lionel Smith, who took over for Madison on the last day of minicamp, which means he is also ahead of Butler.
http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/cowbo...-53-man-roster

[casmith07]

Too early to tell. Have to wait until camp.

[the_h0wey]

From everything I had heard and read Butler is really standing out in these Voluntary practices. Butler.

[gimmesix]

Originally Posted by dantheman41

Hearing and reading that both have been impressive so far during OTA's and Mini Camp, who do you guys think has better chance of making team?

Madison has the ball skills and coverage ability, but lacks height.

Butler has the size and more experience.

I wouldn't mind if both made team : Jenkins, Carr, Claiborne, Scandrick, Butler, Madison

I thought Butler was OK enough to make the practice squad last year. I'd have to see quite a bit of improvement to think he should make the 53.

So I give the edge to Madison, who showed pretty good skills when he wasn't hurt at Arkansas.