Where do you rank Tony Romo out of the 32 starting QBs in the league?

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Originally Posted by RoyTheHammer

Well it must have been pretty tough for him to look good last year since he DIDN'T PLAY.

Kids.. good grief.

As for this year.. he's playing alot better than Romo so far, i'll tell ya that much.

He also has more than two seconds to throw and doesn't have recievers who are mentally inconpatent.

[RoyTheHammer]

Originally Posted by Cowboys&LakersFan

Bookmark it if you want you're the one who's gonna look like a fool in the end. Sure the offensive line is a joke, but they were last year as well and did that stop Romo from killing teams after that Detroit loss? No it didn't and it won't be any different this season. Sure he's struggling right now, but eventually he's gonna find a groove and get this train rolling again. That's what great football players do.

Again Matt Ryan has played four football games against rather weak competition outside of Denver. Forgive me if I'm not kissing his rear like you two and saying he's the best quarterback in football. Let's see him continue this for the rest of the season and actually win a damn playoff game before I say he's better or even in the same vicinity as Tony Romo.

Great football players put mediocre teams on their back and carry them to postseason success. Tony doesn't do that.

..and no one STILL has said that Matt Ryan is the best QB in the game. You need to dust off those glasses, it seems.

..and finally, its funny but neither he, nor anyone else here, cares what you say about him. He's playing much better than Romo right now and im sure he's pretty content with how he's playing and where his team is right now. I don't think he'll be losing any sleep over some kid's comments on a message board.

[venky]

Peyton Manning is still better than Romo, it's not even close. By the end of the season, I'll expect Peyton to be in top 2/3 QB form.

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Originally Posted by RoyTheHammer

Great football players put mediocre teams on their back and carry them to postseason success. Tony doesn't do that.

..and no one STILL has said that Matt Ryan is the best QB in the game. You need to dust off those glasses, it seems.

..and finally, its funny but neither he, nor anyone else here, cares what you say about him. He's playing much better than Romo right now and im sure he's pretty content with how he's playing and where his team is right now. I don't think he'll be losing any sleep over some kid's comments on a message board.

Really who? Eli? He had a great defense and a decent offensive line. You need a competent supporting cast to have success. Ryan has had one of the better offensive lines in the game and a solid run game his whole career and he still hasn't even won a playoff game. At least Romo won a playoff game.

And again it's been four games. Against extremely weak competition. Let me know when he does it for a full season and than maybe I'll consider putting him in the same breathe as Tony. He's playing better than Romo well of course he's got a much better supporting cast and has a weak schedule. He won't keep it up the whole year.

[King Marco III]

Our o line is so terrible, I wouldn't even know where to rank him. I feel like being under constant duress obviously hinders you some. Talent wise, I would say he's top ten. A lot of these guys have good offensive lines and even better skill postion players than we do., so it makes it hard for me to pinpoint where I would rank Romo.

[RoyTheHammer]

Originally Posted by Cowboys&LakersFan

Really who? Eli?

Your best friend, Peyton Manning for one. 2006. Read up on it.

His team sucked that year.. not only was he the QB, he was his team's OC.

That is greatness. Tony is very good.. not great.

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Originally Posted by RoyTheHammer

Your best friend, Peyton Manning for one. 2006. Read up on it.

His team sucked that year.. not only was he the QB, he was his own OC.

LOL he had one of the best offensive lines in the game. Really during his whole time in Indy with the exception of last season.

Your acting like I said Tony was better than Peyton from a career standpoint which is not what I said at all. Tony is in his prime while Peyton is on his last legs.

[RoyTheHammer]

Originally Posted by Cowboys&LakersFan

Ryan has had one of the better offensive lines in the game.

Really? Because Atlanta is in the bottom of the league as far as sacks allowed and QB hits allowed.

[RoyTheHammer]

Originally Posted by Cowboys&LakersFan

LOL he had one of the best offensive lines in the game.

Is that why their running effectiveness was in the bottom half of the league?

Also their defense was in the bottom third of the league as far as ppg given up.

He had little help.. not to mention a defense that gave up the 7th worst ypc in NFL history.

[venky]

Peyton just might be the greatest QB to ever play. I certainly think so. He's had little help his whole career. He leads his team to 10 wins on a broken neck, then the very next year his team wins like 2 games without him.

Also, Peyton NEVER had a good o-line. That is complete revisionist history. He makes his o-line look better due to his incredible mind. He runs the no huddle almost every play and he's able to get ball out very quickly.

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Originally Posted by RoyTheHammer

Is that why their running effectiveness was in the bottom half of the league?

Also their defense was in the bottom third of the league as far as ppg given up.

He had little help.. not to mention a defense that gave up the 7th worst ypc in NFL history.

Dude read what I said again. I NEVER said he had a good defense or run game. I said the offensive line was solid.

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Originally Posted by RoyTheHammer

Really? Because Atlanta is in the bottom of the league as far as sacks allowed and QB hits allowed.

Where'd you get that stat and which year are you referring too?

[JoeyBoy718]

It's funny how people give people grief for putting guys like Ryan over Romo, but then they go and say Romo is top 5. If you can't justify putting Ryan over Romo, then you can't justify putting Romo over Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Peyton, Eli or Ben.

[DABOYZ]

Originally Posted by Lazyking

No, Cutler has the mentality of a child and he's even more prone to mistakes then Romo imo .I also would say Tony is physically tougher then him too..

And the question disregards rookies if you read my op.

OK ill play along. After the Bears game it is announced that one QB threw 5 picks.

Who was that QB, surely not Romo. Yea thats what I thought too. Romo is your Homo, not mine.

[DABOYZ]

Originally Posted by Cowboys&LakersFan

Dude read what I said again. I NEVER said he had a good defense or run game. I said the offensive line was solid.

13,000 posts, 13,000 posts! and yet the rest of us are stupid?! Get a job Bro. Obama season is over next month.