Garrett PC and Practice Tweets- 10/31/12 - Page 4 - Dallas Cowboys Forum

bbailey423 · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by rocboy22

huh? this is how you back up your stance that Witten is not as durable/tough as Irvin was?? OK. I'm done. Not sure why I engaged this long with someone of your ilk.

the feeling is mutual. Running slant routes in that era of the NFL...was one of the toguhest acts of bravado for a NFL player. Many did not do it back then. Many REFUSE to do it today. Irvin not as tough as Witten? Really?

WV Cowboy · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by bbailey423

Never said Witten was not a good player...just that he and Irvin do not belong in the same sentence. Heck if you removed Witten from this team and put Irvin on it....the difference in the results of this era of Cowboys football would be like night and day.

For the last time...Witten is a good player. But the person I originally responded to seemed offended that Witten be associated with what he deemed a drug addict, adulterer etc.....what is it that they say about glass houes? So both you and that poster can bask in the glow of all the numbers these cats in this era of Cowboys football put up...Jerry has thrived because of you.

You may be the only person that follows the NFL that thinks Witten is just a good player.

I thought these were some of the most silly comments I had seen in a while, until, ...

Quote:

Originally Posted by bbailey423

And right of the top I would disagree with you. Because taking the field when you are not healthy and HURTING your team is NOT admirable to me. And that speaks to selfishness and leaderhsip issues. But that runs rampant in Dallas right now...so I can't really say I blame Witten when there is no one in Dallas to stop it.

So again, no one had the guts to take Witten off the field. So you can find taking the field injured as admirable...but not me.

Now I think these are the most silly.

You do know that a large percentage of NFL players, on every team, take the field injured every single Sunday, .. right?

Unbelievable.

rocboy22 · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by bbailey423

the feeling is mutual. Running slant routes in that era of the NFL...was one of the toguhest acts of bravado for a NFL player. Many did not do it back then. Many REFUSE to do it today. Irvin not as tough as Witten? Really?

not sure why I am even responding - but AGAIN - why don't you go learn to READ??

Not ONCE did I say that Irvin was not as tough as Witten.

Adios!!

WV Cowboy · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by rocboy22

That's what happens with a bunch of beetle bailey's who can't read and get all butt-hurt because of it.

I hear ya !

Doomsday101 · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by WV Cowboy

You may be the only person that follows the NFL that thinks Witten is just a good player.

I thought these were some of the most silly comments I had seen in a while, until, ...

Now I think these are the most silly.

You do know that a large percentage of NFL players, on every team, take the field injured every single Sunday, .. right?

Unbelievable.

Let me say Witten is a better TE than Irvin ever was and Mike is a much better WR.

Might as well ask who was better Emmitt Smith or Irvin?

WV Cowboy · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doomsday101

Let me say Witten is a better TE than Irvin ever was and Mike is a much better WR.

Might as well ask who was better Emmitt Smith or Irvin?

I never said one was better than the other, or said pick one over the other.

My first post in this thread alluded to Witten being a gentleman, and a class act off the field.

My second, only saying that someone had missed out noticing that Witten is one of the all time great Cowboys.

M'Kevon · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doomsday101

Let me say Witten is a better TE than Irvin ever was and Mike is a much better WR.

Might as well ask who was better Emmitt Smith or Irvin?

Well, duhhhh. What a ridiculous question. Anyone who is a true blue Cowboys fan could answer this - it's obvious!!!!! The mere fact you had to ask - - -

Dallas · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by rickjameschinaclub

No, he's not... Don't forget that Witten hasn't sniffed a league where DBs could wrestle with receivers and TE...

And further, if Novacek started his career with the Cowboys and Aikman and didn't have the back issue, I seriously think he would have gone down as the greatest TO the Cowboys had.

A lot of setup on that debate of yours. Way to many ifs and what of's for me to get past.