The Cowboys should go for Alex Smith this offseason

[dalboy]

My friend just told me that. He followed up with the comment that Alex Smith is easily a better qb than Romo... just seeing if theres anybody on here that agrees and would like to try to persuade me cus I still Alex Smith dreams about having the capability to play as good as Romo does

[hutch1254]

Send your friend for a random drug test.

[tantrix1969]

he can't be serious, Gabbert could look good with that oline & run game in SF

[bark]

No thanks

[rathalarge]

I'd rather see Orton.

[DFWJC]

Originally Posted by dalboy

My friend just told me that. He followed up with the comment that Alex Smith is easily a better qb than Romo... just seeing if theres anybody on here that agrees and would like to try to persuade me cus I still Alex Smith dreams about having the capability to play as good as Romo does

I actually think David Garrard is a better QB than Alex Smith. He's similar in many ways but has a stronger arm.

[Nexx]

someone give me a gun right now i want to shoot myself.

[Ultra Warrior]

Originally Posted by hutch1254

Send your friend for a random drug test.

[KB1122]

105 quarterback ratings don't grow on trees.

Especially if you're Kyle Orton or David Garrard.

[FiveRings]

Would be a good move for some team that's a real stinker and is looking to see if they can squeeze any of that 1st round potential out, but it's about the last hint we need

[juck]

Alex Smith is pretty awful.

[DFWJC]

Originally Posted by KB1122

105 quarterback ratings don't grow on trees.

Especially if you're Kyle Orton or David Garrard.

Garrard was second in the league in QB rating (>100) just a couple years before his injury. And he had absolutey zero WRs.
I suspect his lifetime stats are very similar or better than Smith's.

[KB1122]

Originally Posted by juck

Alex Smith is pretty awful.

104 qbr. 5th in the league at the moment.

[hutch1254]

Originally Posted by KB1122

104 qbr. 5th in the league at the moment.

The guy has a decent Oline, a running game to back him and a shutdown hard nose defense to lean on. When you get a lead and have a D that can hold it and then some, you can run some pretty safe, high percentage plays that puts a bus driving QB like Alex Smith into statistical position of greatness in the eyes of some.

[BAZ]

Originally Posted by KB1122

104 qbr. 5th in the league at the moment.

Which proves that stat is meaningless, because he's not even starting for his own team.