If Romo stays then Andy Reid should be hired

[JIMMYBUFFETT]

Andy Reid sucks and should head nowhere other than the unemployment office!

[KJJ]

Originally Posted by the kid 05

I personally would welcome Gruden well over the Walrus.

I would welcome him over either walrus Reid and Holmgren.

[egn22]

Originally Posted by KJJ

As bad as Philly looks it wouldn't make any sense to fire one coach who isn't getting it done for another one who isn't getting it done. Reid has been going through some difficult times for quit awhile off the field with his sons drug issues and it really came to a head with the death of one of them during training camp. It may have carried over to his on the field performance as a head coach. You can't just hire a coach off their reputation you have to look at the job they're currently doing and Reid hasn't done a very good job lately. We're seeing a lot of the same issues with Philly that we're seeing with the Cowboys.

[View Full Quote]Having to make the change from McNabb who was in decline to Vick has been part of the problem in Philly but Reid's family issues have probably taken their toll on him. As already mentioned he needs time off. The Cowboys need an experienced coach who's full of energy and is prepared to put everything they have into turning the Cowboys around. Andy Reid wouldn't be the direction I would go.

very strong points

[juck]

Originally Posted by Jenky

You don't even like Romo.

No I dont however if Im stuck with him as a fan of the Cowboys maybe he should be used to maximize his strengths he does have.

[juck]

So what do you guys think about Chucky? He also runs a WCO

[ufcrules1]

Originally Posted by KJJ

As bad as Philly looks it wouldn't make any sense to fire one coach who isn't getting it done for another one who isn't getting it done. Reid has been going through some difficult times for quit awhile off the field with his sons drug issues and it really came to a head with the death of one of them during training camp. It may have carried over to his on the field performance as a head coach. You can't just hire a coach off their reputation you have to look at the job they're currently doing and Reid hasn't done a very good job lately. We're seeing a lot of the same issues with Philly that we're seeing with the Cowboys.

[View Full Quote]Having to make the change from McNabb who was in decline to Vick has been part of the problem in Philly but Reid's family issues have probably taken their toll on him. As already mentioned he needs time off. The Cowboys need an experienced coach who's full of energy and is prepared to put everything they have into turning the Cowboys around. Andy Reid wouldn't be the direction I would go.

Excellent post. I say bring in Sean Payton and hope Romo doesn't run another coach out of town.

[SDCowboy85]

I'd rather have Norv back when the Chargers fire him than Reid.

[KJJ]

Originally Posted by ufcrules1

Excellent post. I say bring in Sean Payton and hope Romo doesn't run another coach out of town.

Sean Payton would be my first choice but I'm not convinced he would want to leave the Saints for the Cowboys and be a head coach for a puppeteer like Jerry. Jerry would have to make some concessions to lure a successful coach like Payton to Dallas.

[Gaede]

Andy Reid getting fired will be the best thing to come out of this season! Philly won't realize how good they had it.

[KJJ]

Originally Posted by SDCowboy85

I'd rather have Norv back when the Chargers fire him than Reid.

I would take Norv as an OC but sure as hell not as a head coach. He's failed with 3 different teams as a head coach how many more failed opportunities is it going to take before people realize he's a good coordinator and not a good head coach?

[ufcrules1]

Originally Posted by KJJ

Sean Payton would be my first choice but I'm not convinced he would want to leave the Saints for the Cowboys and be a head coach for a puppeteer like Jerry. Jerry would have to make some concessions to lure a successful coach like Payton to Dallas.

If I were Payton I wouldn't come to Dallas either. But money does talk and he has family here. However, if he cared about winning, it would probably be better to stay in New Orleans with an elite QB and stronger culture.

We may be able to get Payton but Jerry won't stay out of his business anyway. I would still prefer Payton over JG, Gruden, Holmgren, Reid, or Norv any day.

[TheSkaven]

Oh God know. Don't buy the national media hype. Reid was the benefactor of a great defense under Jim Johnson. His game day coaching is terrible and he never got better.

If we're going to switch, give me Jon Gruden.

[ufcrules1]

Originally Posted by TheSkaven

Oh God know. Don't buy the national media hype. Reid was the benefactor of a great defense under Jim Johnson. His game day coaching is terrible and he never got better.

If we're going to switch, give me Jon Gruden.

Gruden is a jokester.. he would make Dallas more of a circus than it already is.

[KJJ]

Originally Posted by Gaede

Andy Reid getting fired will be the best thing to come out of this season! Philly won't realize how good they had it.

Part of Reid's problem is not having a consistent QB. He came to Philly with McNabb and was successful as long as McNabb was successful. Coaches and QB's are linked when the QB starts to decline it's usually the beginning of the end for the coach.

[KJJ]

Originally Posted by ufcrules1

If I were Payton I wouldn't come to Dallas either. But money does talk and he has family here. However, if he cared about winning, it would probably be better to stay in New Orleans with an elite QB and stronger culture.

We may be able to get Payton but Jerry won't stay out of his business anyway. I would still prefer Payton over JG, Gruden, Holmgren, Reid, or Norv any day.

No quality coach will come to Dallas if Jerry doesn't relinquish some control and stay out of the way. Payton sure as hell won't come here after the success he's had in NO to be another Jerry Jones puppet. They'll be plenty of other teams that will pay him and allow him to do his job.