The X-Factor season 2

[pjtoadie]

Originally Posted by Muhast

I will NEVER understand why they don't let the artists pick their own songs. Why is Britney telling Carly ANYTHING? Carly has more talent than Britney has ever dreamed of. I suppose she could talk to her about what to expect in the business,but not much else. Emblem 3 got worse and worse to me. I really liked the audition, and it went downhill. They need to sing their own style which is like a Sublime type of sound, and move away from the "boy band" image they were directed towards.

And its a shame for 5th harmony that they didn't flip their songs around. The first performance was really good, by far the best they have done. If they could have ended the night on that note, they would be through.

[kristie]

loved that the ladies did this song in both english & spanish. very cool. IMO.

[kristie]

Originally Posted by pjtoadie

Ok my thoughts of the night:

I think Tate is a good singer but he's not really all that special imo. I could go to Nashville and hear 50 guys the same or better than him. Having said all that he does have a huge following and will make it to the finals.

Kristie and everyone on here knows I have been a HUGE fan of Carly's since the auditions but I gotta say I was a little disappointed with her performances tonight. Now I think vocally she was amazing as usual but the arrangement of "Imagine" had me scratching my head and I agreed with Simon. I wish she had LA or Simon as her mentor because I think Brittany did her wrong tonight and she didn't have to change a classic song like they way she did. I would be SHOCKED if Carly didn't make it to the finals and I really hope she wins!!

[View Full Quote]Where do I begin with Emblem3....while I thought they did a decent job tonight I can't stand them to be quite honest! Vocally without a doubt they don't hold a candle to Carly, Tate, or 5th harmony and the crotch grabbing needs to stop! I think they'll make it in the music business because you don't have to have a lot of talent to be big nowadays i.e. Ke$ha, Nicki Minaj, and many others! I think they'll be there next week.

I actually like 5th Harmony and think they're really good vocally but I didn't like how they repeated one of the songs that they did already this season and I agreed with LA, Brittany, and Demi. I don't think they have the following as the other 3 so I think they'll be the ones going home tomorrow. If it was up to me I would have them go through and send home Emblem3.

well, they made it sound different by singing it in both english & spanish, which i think was very cool. LA, briteny & demi are just deaf & dumb.

[pjtoadie]

Originally Posted by kristie

well, they made it sound different by singing it in both english & spanish, which i think was very cool. LA, briteny & demi are just deaf & dumb.

Well yeah it was a little different but come on you're going to defend them no matter what just like I defend Carly

[kristie]

Originally Posted by pjtoadie

Well yeah it was a little different but come on you're going to defend them no matter what just like I defend Carly

i know that.

[pjtoadie]

Spoiler alert if you haven't watched it already!

What crazy results tonight! I'm thrilled that Emblem3 is going home and America got it right! I was sweating bullets at the end when it was between Carly and Emblem3 I'm not going to lie lol. Should be a great finale and hopefully Carly wins!

[Muhast]

Originally Posted by pjtoadie

Spoiler alert if you haven't watched it already!

What crazy results tonight! I'm thrilled that Emblem3 is going home and America got it right! I was sweating bullets at the end when it was between Carly and Emblem3 I'm not going to lie lol. Should be a great finale and hopefully Carly wins!

They know what they are doing, there is no chance it came down to those two. But it makes it intense that there would have been a CHANCE Carly could go home.

I think we all knew it would be one of the two groups.

I like that they didn't do the leaderboard, but I think we all know it was 1/2 Carly and tate, and 3 Fifth harmony.

[kristie]

Originally Posted by pjtoadie

Spoiler alert if you haven't watched it already!

What crazy results tonight! I'm thrilled that Emblem3 is going home and America got it right! I was sweating bullets at the end when it was between Carly and Emblem3 I'm not going to lie lol. Should be a great finale and hopefully Carly wins!

i'm just happy that fifth harmony made it to the finals!!!

[Muhast]

Originally Posted by kristie

i'm just happy that fifth harmony made it to the finals!!!

I thought the first performance they had yesterday was the best performance and singing ANYONE has done on the show, both seasons. It was really really good.

[kristie]

Originally Posted by Muhast

I thought the first performance they had yesterday was the best performance and singing ANYONE has done on the show, both seasons. It was really really good.

i loved it.

[kristie]

probably the most awesome moment in x-factor history:

check out britney's facial expression!!

[pjtoadie]

Originally Posted by Muhast

They know what they are doing, there is no chance it came down to those two. But it makes it intense that there would have been a CHANCE Carly could go home.

I think we all knew it would be one of the two groups.

I like that they didn't do the leaderboard, but I think we all know it was 1/2 Carly and tate, and 3 Fifth harmony.

Yeah I know they did it for drama but being a huge Carly fan I was still nervous

[pjtoadie]

Originally Posted by kristie

probably the most awesome moment in x-factor history:

check out britney's facial expression!!

There will be a lot of gif's of that face if there isn't already

[pjtoadie]

Originally Posted by Muhast

I like that they didn't do the leaderboard, but I think we all know it was 1/2 Carly and tate, and 3 Fifth harmony.

Like I posted last week after the results I really think Carly was #1 and if they would have had her atop the leader board for 3 straight weeks then it wouldn't be as dramatic so they put Tate back as #1. I obviously could be wrong but this show thrives on drama and having Carly against Emblem3 last night at the end showed that.

I by no means think this is only a popularity contest however you have to take in effect that Carly has the most Twitter followers, the most Facebook likes, and she's trending worldwide on Twitter. Also Brittany has 22 million followers on Twitter to urge people to vote for Carly. Anything could happen though and she's not 100% guaranteed to win but I think this is hers to lose

[kristie]

Originally Posted by pjtoadie

There will be a lot of gif's of that face if there isn't already

i've seen a few of them. really funny.