Has there ever been a QB as unclutch?

[JoeyBoy718]

Originally Posted by Super_Kazuya

He never won a road one and that is what almost all of Tony's have been. Romo is 0-5 and White was 0-4. Most successful playoff QBs records (like Troy) are padded by home wins when they are playing an inferior lower seed. Romo has not had those games. Steve Young played something like 19 playoff games and only 3 were on the road. He lost them all.

If he didnt choke away games earlier this season (like against the Seahawks and Bears) he would get a chance to host a playoff game. Didn't Rodgers win the Super Bowl as the 6 seed? Wouldn't that make ALL his playoff games road games? Didn't Big Ben win it as a 6 seed? Stop making excuses. You can't nit pick stats. Elite QBs win games on the road. And you act like Romo has been super clutch at home. He got the majority of his wins on the road this year. You weren't making the "but to win on the road is so hard" argument then.

[cajuncocoa]

Originally Posted by juck

Danny WHite got this team way further than Romo and he wasnt prone to that choketitude lol

Let's be fair: Danny White had a much better team around him than Tony has.

[DWhite Fan]

Originally Posted by intelmax

Danny white

Don't even try You have no clue about what you just posted...

[DWhite Fan]

Originally Posted by Super_Kazuya

Danny White was 0-4 and sucked horribly in these types of game. Try again.

FAIL Ask Atlanta how much he failed. You pulled that 0-4 stat out your rear end and it proves you are clueless...

[DWhite Fan]

Originally Posted by cajuncocoa

Let's be fair: Danny White had a much better team around him than Tony has.

Danny also faced stronger teams and more HOF QBs than Romo has...

[noshame]

All I do know is, if we lock this guy up to a long term deal, we're done. Romo will be 33 next year and his issues are not going to get any better. At the very least we have to give him some compitition, and tell him his job is on the line.

[juck]

14 million!!!!! folks. 14!!!!

[Wood]

Originally Posted by intelmax

Danny white

white lead them to 3 championship games. Not sure that counts as a choke because he needed to get thru few playoff games to get to championship game.

I honestly can't find anyone who has been to more elimination games and not moved on. I will have to run a query.

[Disturbed]

So, would Dallas have won last night if Orton would have played instead of Turnover Tony Romo?

[Wood]

Originally Posted by Disturbed

So, would Dallas have won last night if Orton would have played instead of Turnover Tony Romo?

same results at fraction of the cost.

[DWhite Fan]

Originally Posted by Disturbed

So, would Dallas have won last night if Orton would have played instead of Turnover Tony Romo?

Nope, cause Orton is just as INT prone. He has proved that time and again...

[TheCoolFan]

If the Cowboys were making the NFC Championship game and just falling short then I'd give the QB a free pass. Like Favre would always run into the Cowboys and could never win until Dallas was out of the Packers' path.

But Romo...we're talking about the final game of the season to just get in the playoffs

[Super_Kazuya]

Originally Posted by JoeyBoy718

If he didnt choke away games earlier this season (like against the Seahawks and Bears) he would get a chance to host a playoff game. Didn't Rodgers win the Super Bowl as the 6 seed? Wouldn't that make ALL his playoff games road games? Didn't Big Ben win it as a 6 seed? Stop making excuses. You can't nit pick stats. Elite QBs win games on the road. And you act like Romo has been super clutch at home. He got the majority of his wins on the road this year. You weren't making the "but to win on the road is so hard" argument then.

LOL, I thought this was about "clutch" games, not regular season performance. You can't seem to make up your mind. Again, your hero Troy sucked in these exact type of games. No matter what exceptions you throw out it doesn't change that the vast majority of quarterbacks don't win these types of games.

I'll say it again since you didn't hear me: your hero Troy sucked in these types of games!

[Disturbed]

Originally Posted by Super_Kazuya

LOL, I thought this was about "clutch" games, not regular season performance. You can't seem to make up your mind. Again, your hero Troy sucked in these exact type of games. No matter what exceptions you throw out it doesn't change that the vast majority of quarterbacks don't win these types of games.

I'll say it again since you didn't hear me: your hero Troy sucked in these types of games!

It is like living the movie "groundhog day"....big final game to decide season every year....same result.

[JoeyBoy718]

Originally Posted by Super_Kazuya

LOL, I thought this was about "clutch" games, not regular season performance. You can't seem to make up your mind. Again, your hero Troy sucked in these exact type of games. No matter what exceptions you throw out it doesn't change that the vast majority of quarterbacks don't win these types of games.

I'll say it again since you didn't hear me: your hero Troy sucked in these types of games!

Troy isn't my hero. I find it pointless to compare players to players of the past. I just gave you a few examples. Want more? Wasn't Eli's win in the conference championship last year in San Francisco? Weren't his two games against the Cowboys and Packers in his first Super Bowl run on the road? Weren't all 3 of Big Ben's and Rodgers's games on the road when they won th Super Bowl as the 6 seed? In Brady's first Super Bowl run he beat the Steelers in Pittsburgh on the road in the conference championship. He beat the Steelers in Pittsburgh on the road again in his 3rd Super Bowl run. Peyton won a game on the road in Baltimore during his Super Bowl run. As you see, I'm only including Super Bowl runs. These QBs have won a lot more road playoff games in seasons their team didnt win the Super Bowl.

And correction: All 3 of Eli's games in his first Super Bowl run were on the road because they were the 5 seed.