P. Manning INT vs Romo's INT

[jobberone]

Originally Posted by CATCH17

Dunno. Ask Monte Kiffin.

Well, it wasn't a trick question and its an important one if you're going to discuss great QBs and use championships as a cornerstone for success.

He did have two in 58 and 59. The Colts won another championship in 68 but Morrall was the QB for the vast majority of that season. And they lost the SB to the Jets.

Here is, in the opinion of many, either the greatest or 2nd greatest QB of all time and most base that on actually watching the guy play including calling his own plays. Which brings us to the story of Manning who also runs his own offense. I don't think the overwhelming majority of people here understand that importance of any of that.

Teams win championships and QBs are particularly important for that but not the only thing. Obviously the more championships the easier it is to consider them 'great'. But there's more to it than that. And that's how many many people who put people in the HOF and others who lend their expertise in other ways feel evaluation is multifactorial. So maybe the whole thing is just not as simple as how many or how few championships you won.

[CowboyChris]

Originally Posted by CATCH17

Would you rather have Big Ben with your season on the line or Peyton Manning?

put me down for Big Ben

[CowboysYanksLakers]

Manning's playoff record isn't that great... FACT

[Gameover]

Originally Posted by Clove

Romo fans have hit rock bottom. Poor people, your misery shall continue until this bum is gone. Forget Payton, he has jewelry and skins on the wall. Our problem is this choker we have, but continue your moral victory walk of shame.

preach

[Bowdown27]

I understand why everyone would bring up tony with how Peyton screwed the game up today but he's won a Super Bowl. We haven't in over 15 years. Peyton is definitely a big time choker but no comparison with tonyv

[Rack Bauer]

Originally Posted by Bowdown27

I understand why everyone would bring up tony with how Peyton screwed the game up today but he's won a Super Bowl. We haven't in over 15 years. Peyton is definitely a big time choker but no comparison with tonyv

Be "he" do you mean the Indianapolis Colts? Pretty sure that SB was a team effort.

[DandyDon1722]

Originally Posted by JonJon

Quote:

Originally Posted by REDVOLUTION

I like Peyton and he is a great qb.

But Eli gets it done in clutch more than he does. FACT!

IMAGE#1

Posted from Cowboyszone.com App for Android

[Nav22]

If football was all about QB play, Aaron Rodgers would never lose a game. Learn the sport, people.

[DandyDon1722]

Originally Posted by DandyDon1722

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonJon

Quote:

Originally Posted by REDVOLUTION

I like Peyton and he is a great qb.

But Eli gets it done in clutch more than he does. FACT!

IMAGE#1




Posted from Cowboyszone.com App for Android

The only difference between Eli and Peyton is that the sure Ints werent dropped on Eli - Fact!


Posted from Cowboyszone.com App for Android

[CATCH17]

Originally Posted by Rack Bauer

Be "he" do you mean the Indianapolis Colts? Pretty sure that SB was a team effort.

And his Superbowl was a Bigtime team effort.

He carried them in the regular season but got to the post season and tried to choke.

Ill never forget how bad that Colts D was in the regular season and they turned into one of the best defenses in football pretty much over night during that playoff run.

[Beast_from_East]

Originally Posted by HoustonSucks

Is no one talking about P. Mannings last INT.?

He didn't even have a jailbreak in his face. Peyton is one of my favorites, but this should show good and great and HOF QBs can screw up at times. At the worst time.

This sucks.

No saying this excuses Romo, but they just had a stat on ESPN that this is the 8th "one and done" for Manning. This means he has lost his first playoff game of the post season 8 times already.


8 "one and dones"..................EPIC chokeville.

[jbz64]

Originally Posted by Stinger_Splash

Peyton Manning, a freaking future Hall of Fame QB with a superbowl ring vs an undrafted QB choke artist who has 1 playoff win in his career. Get off Romo's jock.

Peyton is 1 and DONE in 8 playoff seasons. He's definitely a choke artist for being a 1st overall pick and leading his teams to 12 plus wins in regular seasons. He's a All-World regular season QB that's for sure but he definitely chokes just like he was at Tennessee.

[Beast_from_East]

At least Romo does his choking in the regular season.

[Ratmatt]

Originally Posted by CashMan

He has a SB ring, no comparison.

That about says it all.

[CATCH17]

Originally Posted by Ratmatt

That about says it all.

So does Trent Dilfer and Mannings post season Championship run wasn't a whole lot better than Dilfers.