Rank your top 10 Recievers

[LatinMind]

Calvin Johnson
Andre Johnson
Larry Fitzgerald
Dez Bryant
Brandon Marshall
AJ Green
Michael Crabtree
Julio Jones
Victor Cruz
Reggie Wayne

[TheXFactor]

Originally Posted by jamesdojr

I'm not factoring in injuries or stats. My top 10 are the most talented guys who strike the most fear into opposing defensive backs who have to prepare for them on game day. These are guys you most hate to see line up against you on game day...

1. Dez Bryant
2. Calvin Johnson
3. AJ Green
4. Andre Johnson
5. Larry Fitzgerald
6. Julio Jones
7. Brandin Marshall
8. Hakeem Nicks
9. Roddy White
10. Miles Austin

___________________________________________

Miles Austin ahead of Reggie Wayne? D. Thomas? Vincent Jackson?

[Joshmil53]

Originally Posted by TheXFactor

Miles Austin ahead of Reggie Wayne? D. Thomas? Vincent Jackson?

Yeah.. that list... yeah..

[TheXFactor]

Originally Posted by Joshmil53

Yeah.. that list... yeah..

Well when your list has Dez ahead of Megatron there's something wrong right off the bat......

[ringmaster]

Originally Posted by TheXFactor

1. Megatron
2. Dez
3. AJ Green
4.Brandon Marshall
5. Reggie Wayne (getting old but still good)
6. Larry Fitzgerald
7. Andre Johnson
8. Roddy White
9. Julio Jones
10 . Vincent Jackson/Marcus Colston

Yes I know I cheated,but I couldn't decide between the last two. VJ had a great year, and Colston has been putting up stats consistently his whole career (having Brees throwing to you helps)

1.Calvin "Megatron" Johnson
2.AJ Green
3.Dez Bryant
4.Roddy White
5.Demaryius Thomas
6.Julio Jones
7.Brandon Marshall
8.Andre Johnson
9.Victor Cruz
10.Vincent Jackson

[TheXFactor]

Originally Posted by ringmaster

1.Calvin "Megatron" Johnson
2.AJ Green
3.Dez Bryant
4.Roddy White
5.Demaryius Thomas
6.Julio Jones
7.Brandon Marshall
8.Andre Johnson
9.Victor Cruz
10.Vincent Jackson

I like your list except I don't know why Victor Cruz is on and not Reggie Wayne? It's not just you, there are many lists without him.

[ringmaster]

Originally Posted by TheXFactor

I like your list except I don't know why Victor Cruz is on and not Reggie Wayne? It's not just you, there are many lists without him.

Reggie Wayne is good if I did a top 15 list Wayne, would definitely be on it as for Cruz he is in my eyes a top 10 wr even though he had sort of a sophmore slump sort to speak he had to carry the slack in that Giant offense for most of the season due to the injuries to Nicks, and I think he did a servicable job for the most part.

[Romo 2 Austin]

Based primarily on 2012

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Andre Johnson
3. AJ Green
4. Brandon Marshall
5. DeMaryious Thomas
6. Dez Bryant
7. Julio Jones
8. Roddy White
9. Vincent Jackson
10. Michael Crabtree

Most interesting is how everyone was proclaiming Crabtree a huge bust but once he had a proper offense he blew up. Guy is a stud and will be for the next decade, I could see him moving into the top 5 next year. I think D.Thomas overplayed his talent due to the addition of Peyton Manning. Calvin Johnson and Andre Johnson both had their tickets to Canton certified during this season. Marshall is a few more good years away from HoF consideration. I think next year AJ Green may take the #1 spot, might take two years though.

[CarlAllDay]

Originally Posted by lqmac1

Dez Bryant:

REC: 92..... REC YDS: 1,382.... TD'S:12......


Victor Cruz:

REC: 86..... REC YDS: 1,092..... TD'S 10....

That's just 3 of the most important " Aspects ", BUDDY!

Case closed! Dez is easily top 5 no debate

[CowboyMcCoy]

Originally Posted by TheXFactor

1. Megatron
2. Dez
3. AJ Green
4.Brandon Marshall
5. Reggie Wayne (getting old but still good)
6. Larry Fitzgerald
7. Andre Johnson
8. Roddy White
9. Julio Jones
10 . Vincent Jackson/Marcus Colston

Yes I know I cheated,but I couldn't decide between the last two. VJ had a great year, and Colston has been putting up stats consistently his whole career (having Brees throwing to you helps)

Sell me on Dez at number 2.

[Sarge]

Originally Posted by dantheman41

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Roddy White
3. Julio Jones
4. AJ Green
5. Dez Bryant
6. Brandon Marshall
7. Demaryius Thomas
8. Vincent Jackson
9. Andre Johnson
10. Percy Harvin, when healthy

If you don't have Larry Fitz in your top 10 - well................

[SkinsandTerps]

Originally Posted by Romo 2 Austin

Based primarily on 2012

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Andre Johnson
3. AJ Green
4. Brandon Marshall
5. DeMaryious Thomas
6. Dez Bryant
7. Julio Jones
8. Roddy White
9. Vincent Jackson
10. Michael Crabtree

Now that is a good list.

Pretty much agree with that...except you need Fitz somewhere.

Lists with Reggie Wayne and Miles Austin...no way.

[mmillman]

Originally Posted by TheXFactor

1. Megatron
2. Dez
3. AJ Green
4.Brandon Marshall
5. Reggie Wayne (getting old but still good)
6. Larry Fitzgerald
7. Andre Johnson
8. Roddy White
9. Julio Jones
10 . Vincent Jackson/Marcus Colston

Yes I know I cheated,but I couldn't decide between the last two. VJ had a great year, and Colston has been putting up stats consistently his whole career (having Brees throwing to you helps)

calvin johnson
Fitz
Andre Johnson
Green
Julio Jones
Roddy White
Brandon Marshall
Thomas
Jackson
Dez

[CowboyChris]

1. Calvin Johnson
2. AJ Green
3. Brandon Marshall
4. Dez Bryant
5. DeMaryious Thomas
6. Andre Johnson
7. Julio Jones
8. Larry Fitzgerald
9. Vincent Jackson
10. Wes Welker

[December90]

Originally Posted by Shinywalrus

Not sure how to respond to a statement with no arguments.

I simply don't see how a guy who runs rounded off routes, still cuts off routes, can't routinely be trusted with option routes and needs individual coaching on the playcall can be "no question" in the top 5 of a position group.

Dez is physically and mentally not in the same league as Fitzgerland, Calvin, Andre and AJ. He's just not, and there's no shame in it, because no one else is either. Top 10 seems reasonable for him on the back of an excellent second half of the season, but "no question top 5" with no arguments isn't a very compelling statement.

Redskins fan here:

Dez bryant is not a top 5 WR "Yet"

In the 2nd half of last season he started to demonstrate clearly that he could be.

If Dez gets his head on straight he scares the hell out of me. He has the physical abilities to match up with anyone. It is the mental game that is holding him back and he has made solid strides there and there is no reason to think that he wont continue to mature.