Kiper Invitational - Spreadsheet - Dallas Cowboys Forum

xwalker · 02-21-2013

I created a spreadsheet while trying to grade the draft.

Please review, especially the picks gained or given up from trades.

(click twice to enlarge, you will need to pan right-left to see everything)

JonJon · 02-21-2013

Wow great job!

DFWJC · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonJon

Wow great job!

X2

That required some effort.
Thanks

Risen Star · 02-22-2013

Yes, we appreciate the effort.

Sifillest · 02-22-2013

This is pretty dope.

Risen Star · 02-22-2013

Is this in the order of how you graded it?

xwalker · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by Risen Star

Is this in the order of how you graded it?

Yes, but I would consider changing my grades if somebody convinces me that they should get a better grade.

DFWJC · 02-22-2013

Atlanta wasn't my team, but liked their draft, value-wise.

I had Tampa at or near the top too, so we agree there.
I liked Buffalo (

) so we agreed there too.

Questfor6 · 02-22-2013

Although the draft happened before Ogletree's arrest I won't complain because he'll prolly be on the board for the Texans at 27 now. Before the arrest however Ogletree was a top 15 pick and Terrence Williams is a first round talent WR.

ABQcowboyJR · 02-22-2013

My first round pick is better than everyone in front of me except Sheldon. I got three for sure big time contributers in Lane Okafor and Bell. I think Blidi is gonna be a good corner, had a second round grade on him. You should move me up

DFWJC · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABQcowboyJR

My first round pick is better than everyone in front of me except Sheldon. I got three for sure big time contributers in Lane Okafor and Bell. I think Blidi is gonna be a good corner, had a second round grade on him. You should move me up

You think Lane Johnson at 11 is better value than those in front for you?
I like your draft but that is very debatable. I actually had Johnson valued slightly below where you picked him and all all the 1st rd picks for teams ahead of you rated higher than they were taken. I've seen Johnson rated as low as in the 20s, though he is better than that.

Ricahrdson at 19
Ansah at 21
Te'o at 25
Moore at 8

all pretty decent values

Now you getting Okafor at 45...now that was good ...imo. I bet that is why he has your team rated so high.

xwalker · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABQcowboyJR

My first round pick is better than everyone in front of me except Sheldon. I got three for sure big time contributers in Lane Okafor and Bell. I think Blidi is gonna be a good corner, had a second round grade on him. You should move me up

In review, you did have a good draft. The biggest issue that I had with your draft was Okafor. It appears that SD is staying with the 3-4 and I'm not certain that Okafor is a good fit at OLB.

Sifillest · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by DFWJC

You think Lane Johnson at 11 is better value than those in front for you?
I like your draft but that is very debatable. I actually had Johnson valued slightly below where you picked him and all all the 1st rd picks for teams ahead of you rated higher than they were taken. I've seen Johnson rated as low as in the 20s, though he is better than that.

Ricahrdson at 19
Ansah at 21
Te'o at 25
Moore at 8

all pretty decent values

Now you getting Okafor at 45...now that was good ...imo. I bet that is why he has your team rated so high.

Okafor being swiped two picks before me made me very very sad.

ABQcowboyJR · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by DFWJC

You think Lane Johnson at 11 is better value than those in front for you?
I like your draft but that is very debatable. I actually had Johnson valued slightly below where you picked him and all all the 1st rd picks for teams ahead of you rated higher than they were taken. I've seen Johnson rated as low as in the 20s, though he is better than that.

Ricahrdson at 19
Ansah at 21
Te'o at 25
Moore at 8

all pretty decent values

Now you getting Okafor at 45...now that was good ...imo. I bet that is why he has your team rated so high.

It's all how one has their board setup. I didn't have a first round grade on Ansah or teo. The Moore pick was great IMO.

DFWJC · 02-22-2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by xwalker

In review, you did have a good draft. The biggest issue that I had with your draft was Okafor. It appears that SD is staying with the 3-4 and I'm not certain that Okafor is a good fit at OLB.

Now that's going the extra mile.

To me, Okafor seemed like very good value there...but maybe not as much so for that scheme.

xw, I notice that your were happy with your draft as well.