Poll::trade senerio - Dallas Cowboys Forum

Q_the_man · 01-17-2005

If Arizona is on the clock with the #8 pick, would u trade the #11 and 2nd rounder for the #8 if MW is there.

Q_the_man · 01-17-2005

I say yes, maybe they could throw their 3rd rounder in there.....it would be nice if they took the #20 and 2nd, with Coakley as a throw in....

tyke1doe · 01-17-2005

No.
We need defense.

Merlin · 01-17-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by Q_the_man

If Arizona is on the clock with the #8 pick, would u trade the #11 and 2nd rounder for the #8 if MW is there.

No. Thats too much to give up move up three spots. A first and a third and maybe a sixth is approximately the value for moving up three spots. Look at the draft value chart stickied to the top of this forum. We don't have a third this year either.

jterrell · 01-17-2005

No. I dont rate MW that highly.
I would certinaly take him at 20 in a split second but 11 is probably a bit too high.

Boy's fan in Giant land · 01-17-2005

He's good, but not THAT good. We can manage quite well next season with our existing corps of wideouts if need be. As someone else mentioned, we need defense.

Avery · 01-17-2005

We can't give up a 2nd to move up three spots. If we had a 3rd we could, but then again, we ain't got a 3rd.

I don't see us trading up this year despite the two first rounders. Most of the guys we'll need will not go in the top 5 - 8 anyway.

Big Country · 01-17-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by Q_the_man

If Arizona is on the clock with the #8 pick, would u trade the #11 and 2nd rounder for the #8 if MW is there.

If Williams is there I'd trade to 9 or 10 not 8 because AZ isn't going to pick a WR... they have Boldin and Fitzgerald... Dallas should worry about someone else picking up those WRs earlier anyway than worrying about the 8 spot.