Favorite 3 QBs not on the Cowboys.

[Romo 2 Austin]

I specified not on Cowboys since I don't want either McGee or Kitna getting 500 votes, cause I know i'd vote for them.

Remember. This is favorite not best-


1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Vince Young
3. Matt Schaub.

[BraveHeartFan]

1. Phillip Rivers
2. Peyton Manning
3. Brett Favre

[8FOR!3]

1. Tyler Thigpen
2. Vince Young
3. I don't know?

[Sonny#9]

1. Manning
2. Rodgers
3. Brees

P.S. I figured there would be several shots at Campbell...I am disappointed in you all

[Romo 2 Austin]

Originally Posted by Sonny#9

1. Manning
2. Rodgers
3. Brees

P.S. I figured there would be several shots at Campbell...I am disappointed in you all

i like Campbell, and I dont hate McNabb like others on these forums do. Eli Manning and Mark Sanchez are the QBs I hate the most.

[Hostile]

1. Brett Favre. Can't help it, I love the guy. I would have killed to play with him.

2. Peyton Manning. Quite simply the best I have ever seen play the game.

3. John Elway. If they were making a QB mold, he is it.


Current player who would replace Elway...Phillip Rivers. I respect toughness.

[CowboysFaninBaltimore]

1). Peyton Manning: Okay maybe 5 years ago I would have said Brady. But Peyton Manning is truly awesome, and isn't about breaking personal stats. The man will be around for another 7 years atleast. If he keeps himself injury free. Unfornatually living in this horrible town that cries over the Colts. They can't stand him. Whatever **** em they have no idea what its like supporting a winner.

2). Ben Roethlisberger: Yes I know this forum hates the Steelers. But you can't help but love what this man does. He is very clutch when you need him in the 4th Quarter. He really isn't a flashy guy, but he will go down as one of the greatest QB's ever. Yeah go ahead laugh but the dude will be in the HOF.

3). John Elway: Took more beatings to help his team win when it matters. Those two Superbowls he won in the late 90's were easily some of the most classic games I've ever seen.

[kimorah86]

ben R
Brett F

[ZeroClub]

1. Bruce Gradkowski - A hard luck journeyman with moxie. If his luck would change, I think he'd put together a better than average career.

2. Matt Moore - Another underdog. I liked him when he was in Dallas.

3. Vince Young - His uncommon athleticism ... I enjoy seeing him play.

[Joe Rod]

I assume we are discussing current players?

1. Drew Brees - Love the kind of leadership he brings to this team and the way he spreads the ball around. Seems a perfect fit for Sean Peyton's offense.

2. Kurt Warner - When he is hot, it is one of the most unbelievable displays of precision I have ever seen. He is currently #1, 2 and 3 in most passing yards in a Superbowl. His playoff numbers are off the charts.

3. Peyton Manning - When his career is completed, I really believe he will be up there as one of the top five ever to play the position. Unbelievable player on the field and very charismatic off.

Rivers is pretty good as well, but I still hate him for beating Dallas this season. It may wear off by next season.

[dillinger319]

Peyton Manning

Phillip Rivers

Matthew Stafford

[Muhast]

Some of you have odd lists lol.


Manning, Brees, Rivers.

[daschoo]

matt schaub
vince young
carson palmer

[CowboyMike]

1. Peyton Manning - My favorite player in the league and all time greatest QB to play the game.
2. Philip Rivers - Any player that plays an AFC Championship game with a torn ACL while his all pro running back is moping on the sidelines with a hammy injury gets my vote.
3. Kurt Warner - What's not to like about the guy?

[8FOR!3]

I guess a lot of people here like Philip Rivers.

Add Kurt Warner and Matt Moore to my list.