Jacoby Ford or Dexter McCluster

[The Realist]

Originally Posted by jobberone

I don't know where you're getting this from. But I know he returned punts in his career.

http://www.olemisssports.com/ViewArticle.dbml?SPSID=12787&SPID=737&DB_LANG=C&DB _OEM_ID=2600&ATCLID=542684&Q_SEASON=2009

His career numbers are there for everyone to see.

Garbage in the return game.

If you are drafting him as a return man you are drafting a complete unknown.

[jobberone]

Originally Posted by The Realist

http://www.olemisssports.com/ViewArticle.dbml?SPSID=12787&SPID=737&DB_LANG=C&DB _OEM_ID=2600&ATCLID=542684&Q_SEASON=2009

His career numbers are there for everyone to see.

Garbage in the return game.

If you are drafting him as a return man you are drafting a complete unknown.

We were comparing Ford and McCluster not McCluster vs everybody. I'm aware of his stats which don't compare with Ford's stats. I've been a Ford fan for four years and have kids at Clemson. I don't think Ford is as good as McCluster but the difference isn't huge. McCluster is as quick as he is fast and he's stronger than Ford. I'm basing all this on the eyeball test. Ford is faster on the track. McCluster looks faster on the field to me although it may be a result of his quickness and speed. Totally subjective. Spiller looks as fast or faster than Ford on the field but is not as fast on the track. Again subjective.

[Malcolm Kelly]

I would rather have the Cowboys choose Dexter McCluster. He has a huge upside and he can play running back and slot receiver. He is putting on a show at the Senior Bowl. McCluster is exactly the kind of player that the Cowboys could really regret passing over a few years from now. His upside makes taking him worth the risk.