How many comp picks did Adam get right

[OILERMAN]

I'm curious. I noticed he was wrong about Ian Gold and the Broncos picks but wondered how he did overall. Anyone chcek?

He nailed the Titans picks.

[WoodysGirl]

did a quick search of the zone. So here's the thread where he posted his suggestions and his explanation

http://cowboyszone.com/forums/showthread.php?t=21502

As I alluded to earlier, the NFL adds non-compensatory picks if fewer than 32 comp picks are awarded. The non-compensatory picks are given, in order, to the teams that would be drafting if there were an eighth round. If there are 26 true comps, for example, the NFL would give additional picks to the teams that would have the first six picks in the eighth round, if there were one. This year, though, I’m projecting that there won’t be any non-compensatory picks needed. By my calculations, there will be 32 true compensatory picks awarded. In fact, there could have been a 33rd (for Jermaine Wiggins), if there wasn’t a limit of 32. Here are the projected picks, along with the compensatory player, their games played/started and their average contract value –




THIRD ROUND

Tennessee (Jevon Kearse, $7.83 million, 14 GP/14 GS)

Kansas City (John Tait, $5.61 million, 13/13)

St. Louis (Grant Wistrom, $5.5 million, 9/9)
[View Full Quote]


FOURTH ROUND

Denver (Bert Berry, $5.0 million, 16/16, Pro Bowl)

New England (Damien Woody, $5.17 million, 16/16)

Indianapolis (Marcus Washington, $4.17 million, 16/16, Pro Bowl)

Tennessee (Robaire Smith, $4.39 million, 16/16)



FIFTH ROUND

New England (Ted Washington, $3.5 million, 16/16)

Carolina (Jeno James, $3.52 million, 14/14)

Philadelphia (Carlos Emmons, $3.3 million, 15/15)

Carolina (Reggie Howard, $3.62 million, 15/3)

San Francisco (Jason Webster, $3.01 million, 10/9)

Philadelphia (Bobby Taylor, $2.95 million, 10/0)

Oakland (Charlie Garner, $2.91 million, 3/3 IR)



SIXTH ROUND

Indianapolis (David Macklin, $2.6 million, 16/16)

St. Louis (Brian Young, $2.51 million, 15/15)

Carolina (Deon Grant, $2.42 million, 16/16)

Dallas (Ebenezer Ekuban, $2.52 million, 16/11)

Baltimore (Marcus Robinson, $2.25 million, 16/7)

Oakland (Matt Stinchcomb, $1.9 million, 16/16)

Philadelphia (Bobbie Williams, $1.75 million, 16/16)



SEVENTH ROUND

San Francisco (Tai Streets, $1.5 million, 13/12)

Seattle (Reggie Tongue, $1.33 million, 16/16)

St. Louis (John St. Clair, $1.3 million, 14/14)

Dallas (Mario Edwards, $1.5 million, 15/3)

San Francisco (Travis Kirschke, $1.6 million, 16/1)

Tampa Bay (Tom Tupa, $935,000, 16 games)

St. Louis (David Loverne, $867,000, 15/13)

Philadelphia (Marco Coleman, $785,000, 16/16)

Seattle (Willie Williams, $760,000, 16/10)

New England (Bobby Hamilton, $685,000, 16/15)

Cincinnati (Matt O’Dwyer, $685,000, PUP 4/0)

[AdamJT13]

I got 22 of 32 correct, plus six others within one round (five of which I said were possible). Obviously, I didn't hit enough of the cutoff points between rounds, and I was wrong about two of the three bubble players (Matt O'Dwyer and Jermaine Wiggins). And I was wrong about Cornell Green (.700, 0/0) counting in the comp equation. Also, I wrongly lowered the values for Ian Gold and Mario Edwards after they were cut.

But the NFL didn't do anything that can't be easily explained, which is always a good thing.

[Phrozen Phil]

Originally Posted by AdamJT13

I got 22 of 32 correct, plus six others within one round (five of which I said were possible). Obviously, I didn't hit enough of the cutoff points between rounds, and I was wrong about two of the three bubble players (Matt O'Dwyer and Jermaine Wiggins). And I was wrong about Cornell Green (.700, 0/0) counting in the comp equation. Also, I wrongly lowered the values for Ian Gold and Mario Edwards after they were cut.

But the NFL didn't do anything that can't be easily explained, which is always a good thing.

An admirable record. I doubt many othrs could come as close. Thanks, as always..

[Carlito]

Originally Posted by AdamJT13

I got 22 of 32 correct, plus six others within one round (five of which I said were possible). Obviously, I didn't hit enough of the cutoff points between rounds, and I was wrong about two of the three bubble players (Matt O'Dwyer and Jermaine Wiggins). And I was wrong about Cornell Green (.700, 0/0) counting in the comp equation. Also, I wrongly lowered the values for Ian Gold and Mario Edwards after they were cut.

But the NFL didn't do anything that can't be easily explained, which is always a good thing.

Adam,

I don't know how you do it, but I sure am glad you do it!!!

Thanks

[trickblue]

Originally Posted by AdamJT13

I got 22 of 32 correct, plus six others within one round (five of which I said were possible). Obviously, I didn't hit enough of the cutoff points between rounds, and I was wrong about two of the three bubble players (Matt O'Dwyer and Jermaine Wiggins). And I was wrong about Cornell Green (.700, 0/0) counting in the comp equation. Also, I wrongly lowered the values for Ian Gold and Mario Edwards after they were cut.

But the NFL didn't do anything that can't be easily explained, which is always a good thing.

You're Fired...

naahhh... not really... you know your stuff...

[hipfake08]

This is off the NFL web site.

ROUND ROUND CHOICE/
OVERALL SELECTION TEAM
3 33-96 Tennessee
3 34-97 Denver
3 35-98 Seattle
3 36-99 Kansas City
3 37-100 New England
3 38-101 Denver
4 33-134 St. Louis
4 34-135 Indianapolis
4 35-136 Tennessee
5 33-169 Carolina
5 34-170 New England
5 35-171 Carolina
5 36-172 Philadelphia
5 37-173 Indianapolis
5 38-174 San Francisco
6 33-207 Carolina
6 34-208 Dallas
6 35-209 Dallas
6 36-210 St. Louis
6 37-211 Philadelphia
6 38-212 Oakland
6 39-213 Baltimore
6 40-214 Oakland
7 33-247 Philadelphia
7 34-248 San Francisco
7 35-249 San Francisco
7 36-250 St. Louis
7 37-251 St. Louis
7 38-252 Philadelphia
7 39-253 Tampa Bay
7 40-254 Seattle
7 41-255 New England

Following are the compensatory free agents lost and signed by the clubs that will receive compensatory picks in the 2005 NFL Draft:

BALTIMORE Lost: Marcus Robinson

CAROLINA Lost: Greg Favors, Deon Grant, Reggie Howard, Jeno James
Signed: Brandon Short

DALLAS Lost: Mario Edwards, Ebenezer Ekuban

DENVER Lost: Bert Berry, Keith Burns, Ian Gold
Signed: Marco Coleman

INDIANAPOLIS Lost: David Macklin, Marcus Washington

KANSAS CITY Lost: Jonathan Quinn, John Tait
Signed: Chris Bober

NEW ENGLAND Lost: Mike Compton, Bobby Hamilton, Ted Washington, Damien Woody
Signed: Keith Traylor

OAKLAND Lost: Eric Barton, Lorenzo Bromell, Roderick Coleman, Charlie Garner, Rick Mirer, Matt Stinchcomb
Signed: Danny Clark, Bobby Hamilton, Warren Sapp, Ted Washington

PHILADELPHIA Lost: Marco Coleman, Carlos Emmons, Duce Staley, Bobby Taylor, Troy Vincent, Bobbie Williams
Signed: Dhani Jones, Jevon Kearse

ST. LOUIS Lost: David Loverne, John St. Clair, Grant Wistrom, Brian Young

SEATTLE Lost: Randall Godfrey, Shawn Springs, Reggie Tongue, Willie Williams
Signed: Bobby Taylor, Grant Wistrom

SAN FRANCISCO Lost: Travis Kirschke, Tai Streets, Jason Webster

TAMPA BAY Lost: Thomas Jones, Shaun King, Warren Sapp, Aaron Stecker, Tom Tupa, Nate Webster, Todd Yoder
Signed: Keith Burns, Mario Edwards, Charlie Garner, Ian Gold, Jeff Gooch, Matt Stinchcomb

TENNESSEE Lost: Jevon Kearse, Robaire Smith




Total 2005 NFL compensatory draft picks

Philadelphia -- 4
St. Louis -- 4
Carolina -- 3
New England -- 3
San Francisco -- 3
Dallas -- 2
Denver -- 2
Indianapolis -- 2
Oakland -- 2
Seattle -- 2
Tennessee -- 2
Baltimore -- 1
Kansas City -- 1
Tampa Bay -- 1
TOTAL -- 32

[conner01]

pretty impressive considering even the nfl teams can't figure this stuff out.read earlier where the colts wanted more info on there comp picks.maybe they need to just hire adam.lol

[Yeagermeister]

You are the man as always Step.....I mean Adam

[Dayton Cowboy]

from GBN 3/24
http://www.gbnreport.com/index.htm

It mentions the Colts.. They cant really hire Adam due to the conflict of interest the 'Boys VP couldn't work for another team.. good thing he's on our side

Teams unhappy with comp pick awards… At least a couple of teams around the NFL aren’t particularly happy with the compensatory picks they were awarded earlier this week by the NFL. Indianapolis, for example, was expecting to get at least one extra third round pick this year. The Colts did get two comp picks – 4th and 5th rounders – but not the #3 they were expecting. The Colts have gone so far as to ask the NFL for ‘clarification’ on how the picks were assigned. Meanwhile, Indianapolis head coach Tony Dungy diplomatically summed up what a lot of people around the NFL are feeling when he said “just say I don’t understand the system.” The NFL awards comp picks based on a formula which includes a team’s net loss of unrestricted free agents from the previous year, as well as the salaries involved, playing time and post-season honors won. Same story in St. Louis which also expected to be awarded a 3rd round pick this year, although the Rams did get the maximum 4 [View Full Quote]comp picks for this spring’s draft.

[Rockytop6]

You are light years ahead of anybody else. Thanks for sharing your info with us on these boards. It is greatly appreciated.

[RESIN8]

close to 70% right on predictions. I'll take those odds...