If those were the only two guys on the board, I'd take Brockers, as he's the safer bet based on production.
But I don't take either of them. Give me Barron, DeCastro, or any number of others first. If they are the only two I think are worthy of the pick, I trade back.
"Contrary to popular opinion, you CAN lead a horse to water AND make him drink...you just have to hold his head under water long enough."