Vinny to be the starter???? - Page 2 - Dallas Cowboys Forum

zack · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by BrAinPaiNt

Henson sitting all year depends on the teams record towards the end of the year IMO.

Agreed. Let's hope we don't see him this year because that would mean that we are stinking it up.

**BrAinPaiNt** · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by zack

Agreed. Let's hope we don't see him this year because that would mean that we are stinking it up.

Same here...however I WOULD like to see him get some playing time during the second part of the season....maybe a series or so a game in the last 5-7 games....get him a little EXP and get a taste for the live action and speed of the NFL.

**big dog cowboy** · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reef Engineer

Having said that, I'd prefer NOT to sign either of them and let the guys we have battle it out. We need to see what we have and renting a guy for a year or two doesn't make sense to me.

That doesn't sound all that bad to me. If we bring in a vet, is that only delaying a commentment to the QB of our future?

da_boyz_mk · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by big dog cowboy

That doesn't sound all that bad to me. If we bring in a vet, is that only delaying a commentment to the QB of our future?

in my opinion the main reason we will bring in someone like vinnie is for mentoring purposes. kinda like a mediator between players and coaches.

Bill the Butcher · 06-02-2004

Have no clue how this whole thing will shake out. But I gotta say that if Q doesnt look so hot in camp/preseason and Vinny looks good then he indeed SHOULD start. Thats what sports are supposed to be about. Best man for the job regardless!

CantonBound08 · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill the Butcher

Have no clue how this whole thing will shake out. But I gotta say that if Q doesnt look so hot in camp/preseason and Vinny looks good then he indeed SHOULD start. Thats what sports are supposed to be about. Best man for the job regardless!

WHAT? That is not even fair

I think Parcell's has showed in the past that the best player starts. I see no reason why he would change now.

Doomsday101 · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by zack

Come on! Did you see him play last year? He is nothing more than a backup period, a mentor to the young guys. If we rely on him to be the starter for more than 4 games, Dallas could be in big trouble. Trust me, I would love to have him on the team, but only as a back up. Secondly, his signing will confirm to me that Henson will sit the entire year and we can dispell that this guy is going to be thrown into action.

Well if QC is better than Vinny then he should not have a problem beating him out. This notion of saying that Vinny can come but only as a back up is not a great argument when you consider that our starting QB has more than his share of question marks. It is not like Vinny would be coming to a team with an established vet QB already in place that notion is far from reality.

zack · 06-02-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doomsday101

Well if QC is better than Vinny then he should not have a problem beating him out. This notion of saying that Vinny can come but only as a back up is not a great argument when you consider that our starting QB has more than his share of question marks. It is not like Vinny would be coming to a team with an established vet QB already in place that notion is far from reality.

I hear ya, I am all about competition, but I am confident that QC will be the starter. I guess it really doesn't matter. I know his agent was indicating that he wanted to start. I guess we'll see.