If you could only keep 5 players from the current roster

[dfan32]

Originally Posted by Risen Star

I'm not constantly negative.

OK, ...more often than not? Anyway, no offense intended. Your negative views on certain aspects of the Cowboy's do not offend me like they do some. Dont always agree with them but not bothered by it either.

[GIFTS]

1. Ware

2. Romo

3. Sean Lee

4. Witten

5. Jay Ratliff

I chose these guys because Rookies are unpredictable no matter what pick they were chosen at. Jamarcus Russel as an example! So i stuck with tough as nails Top Talent. And yes Ratliff has been Great IMO and would love to see him at DE personally.

I would love to hear peoples opinion on my roster. If they disagree or agree. Thanks.

[Kingsmith88]

Originally Posted by Risen Star

I wouldn't keep either. RBs are indeed a dime a dozen and Witten's on the downside of his career. If you truly had to do this you couldn't use a spot for an over 30 tight end. It'd be foolish.

Keeping Witten I don't care. I'll be Jerry Jones lite on this one.

That is a good point though more addressing the point of a lot of folks choosing Murray, although I love me some Witten.

[Kingsmith88]

Just throwing it out there, I wouldn't Keep Ratliff either.

[GIFTS]

some people are throwing out 5 years? the OP did not say nothing about a time frame. So how are we to look at this? I am guessing if we rebuilt around 5 right?

[jimnabby]

Originally Posted by jimnabby

Smith (21)
Claiborne (22)
Dez (23)
Lee (26)
Carr (26)

Originally Posted by dexternjack

The more I think about it, you are correct. From my list of Dez, Murray, Lee, Claiborne and Smith, I would replace Murray with Carr.

Now that there's a heckuva good list!