Toomer: Romo better than Eli - Dallas Cowboys Forum

Mr Cowboy · 07-05-2012

Adam Schefter

6 minutes ago via WhoSay Broadcast.

Former Giants WR Amani Toomer is on Sirius, saying Tony Romo is a better quarterback than Eli Manning. Agree?

**jobberone** · 07-05-2012

Duh?! Of course. I hate those wingers off the back foot that Eli throws up. It flabbergasts me more don't get intercepted although a lot do except when he plays us.

Doomsday101 · 07-05-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Cowboy

Adam Schefter

6 minutes ago via WhoSay Broadcast.

Former Giants WR Amani Toomer is on Sirius, saying Tony Romo is a better quarterback than Eli Manning. Agree?

I think Romo has shown consistentcy in his play more so than Eli. Not by accident that Romo has never been under 90 in terms of QB ratings. Eli clearly has the hardware but as I have said before his teammates played a big role in that on both sides of the ball, I take nothing away from Eli but he has had some pretty poor seasons to go along with the hardware

bklyn1028 · 07-05-2012

Toomer's a turncoat!!
lol

Cowboys&LakersFan · 07-05-2012

I agree.

StevenOtero · 07-05-2012

Oh boy, I bet this thread will have some original thought.

wittenacious · 07-05-2012

Could Amani Toomer possibly know more and have a better perspective about Eli Manning vs Tony Romo than Marty B does?

Nah, how could that be? /sarcasm

Gemini Dolly · 07-05-2012

Amani must not have been Eli's favorite.

stiletto · 07-05-2012

Anyone with half a brain has to realize that Eli has benefited from better defensive support in the years he went to the Super Bowls. The Cowboys D has been the opposite of clutch in big games. It's not just Romo or Eli. The defense matters too. I dont get why people don't see the real problem. I think they have fixed some glaring issues this off season. #1 replacing Terrance "Leap Frog" Newman.

wittenacious · 07-05-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by stiletto

Anyone with half a brain has to realize that Eli has benefited from better defensive support in the years he went to the Super Bowls. The Cowboys D has been the opposite of clutch in big games. It's not just Romo or Eli. The defense matters too. I dont get why people don't see the real problem. I think they have fixed some glaring issues this off season. #1 replacing Terrance "Leap Frog" Newman.

Provided they got the half that works, anyway. If not... well... that would account for the rest.

zack · 07-05-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by wittenacious

Provided they got the half that works, anyway. If not... well... that would account for the rest.

I came in on the tail end of the broadcast. Anyone hear what he said in support?

wittenacious · 07-05-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by zack

I came in on the tail end of the broadcast. Anyone hear what he said in support?

I didn't get to hear it at all, zack. Just throwing a few jabs based the OP having relayed Adam Schefter's generalized tweet, myself. Maybe somebody here can/will post the Sirius broadcast for us to listen to, if there's a podcast of it to be had later on.

SDCowboy85 · 07-05-2012

Eli's center said Romo is top 4 QB so I wonder if he feels he's better also.

CCBoy · 07-05-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by bklyn1028

Toomer's a turncoat!!
lol

kristie · 07-05-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by wittenacious

I didn't get to hear it at all, zack. Just throwing a few jabs based the OP having relayed Adam Schefter's generalized tweet, myself. Maybe somebody here can/will post the Sirius broadcast for us to listen to, if there's a podcast of it to be had later on.

i hope so because i want to hear what toomer said.