Who would you pick - Dallas Cowboys Forum

gollum · 01-22-2006

If all were available at #18?

Dayton Cowboy · 01-22-2006

Holmes. I think he by far is the best WR coming out in this draft. He runs really good routes, is extremely fast and is a plus on special teams

Cowboy Junkie · 01-22-2006

I choose Mcneil , but the combine will really answer this question for me....

kartr · 01-22-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by gollum

If all were available at #18?

None of them. All good players mind you, but none would have any immediate impact.

gollum · 01-22-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by kartr

None of them. All good players mind you, but none would have any immediate impact.

Who would you select kartr?

ghst187 · 01-22-2006

I think Holmes is the only one of the choices that represents good value for the pick at 18. He's the best WR in this draft and can make the big play and return kicks. Good player. Not sure that 18 is a little high for any of the rest of the guys there save Cutler (whom we don't need and is a little overrated) and Kiwi (whom I don't think fits our scheme that well).
Carpenter would get some votes, but depending on his workout at the combine, 18 could be a little high for him too. He's probably the best fit for us though. Of course, if we could get Lawson in the 2nd, I'd prefer that to Carpenter in the 1st.

Displaced Cowboy · 01-22-2006

I'd take Greenway.

cowboys19 · 01-22-2006

Id take Kiwi

Qwickdraw · 01-22-2006

Kiwi at 18...

that's tempting.

jbsg02 · 01-22-2006

I chose Winston Justice, a RT who is athletic and could help our line a lot.

That being said a few names on there I'd HATE to pass up and wouldn't question them being picked if they were there aince this draft is deep at OT.

Ngata seems like a perfect fit at DT.

Ko Simpson could be the next great FS.

StarMan · 01-23-2006

Jay Cutler.

We'll never win a Super Bowl with Bledsoe.

dwmyers · 01-23-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by gollum

If all were available at #18?

Just one linebacker available at 18? Of the people remaining, I'd probably go McNeil, but I'd rather have a pass rusher out of the first round.

ghst187 · 01-23-2006

[quote=jbsg02]
Ngata seems like a perfect fit at DT.
QUOTE]

three words: MAJOR KNEE INJURY
also injured in bowl game...knee
will be recurring theme IMO. That's the only thing I don't like about him.
Think about Leon Lett before his knee injury and after.

kiheikiwi · 01-23-2006

Mcneil for me, but will wait to see senior bowl.Would love to see our scouts work-up on him.

MDCowboy · 01-25-2006

Greenway. Defense wins championships and he makes a nice bookend with Ware.